A Real Legal Problem For Harmony

By Ed Oswald | Published August 11, 2005, 12:35 PM

A filing by Real with the Securities and Exchange Commission this week indicates that the company has acknowledged its Harmony software could put it in the legal crosshairs of Apple.

Originally reported by Macworld UK, the filing states, "if Apple decides to commence litigation against us in order to prevent interoperation with its products, we may be forced to spend money defending their legal challenge, which could harm our operating results."

However, Real goes on to admit that defending Harmony in court could prove unwinnable. "Although we believe our Harmony technology is legal, there is no assurance that a court would agree with our position," the company writes.

Harmony is a program developed by Real to trick the iPod into thinking tracks downloaded from its music store have Apple's FairPlay digital rights management. The only DRM tracks that the iPod can play natively are those from the iTunes Music Store, which use FairPlay.

Apple shot back publicly last year, equating Real's actions to that of a hacker, and said that it was investigating the legal ramifications. "We strongly caution Real and their customers that when we update our iPod software from time to time it is highly likely that Real's Harmony technology will cease to work with current and future iPods," Apple warned.

In the filing, Real also visited the financial costs of continuing to battle Apple over the technology. Each time Apple updates their software to break Harmony, Real must "incur additional development costs" to ensure that Harmony will operate again.

In addition to fighting Apple over Harmony, Real disclosed it will spend $16 million this year in legal costs associated with its battle with Microsoft over Windows Media Player. In that case, Real has accused Microsoft of abusing its monopoly on the operating system market to promote its media format.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

I though Real already blew the windows media player case out the window with the amazing email from Rob Glaser to Steve Jobs... (in which real basically said drop i-tunes (adopt the RealPlayer) and join with us against microsoft, or we will join up with microsoft and destroy you)

then with Steve Jobs having an even bigger ego, he went out and distributed the email to various people...

/ex-Real employee

Score: 0

|

Comcast deal for NBC Universal is about content, not broadband

Although Comcast is certainly America's largest broadband provider, at least for PCs, in most regards, today's deal with GE may not impact the Internet at all.

The Black Screen Syndrome, or, Tech news in search of the apocalypse

Scott Fulton On Point: This is a story about something that should not have been a story, about something that at one time was a story.

Five compact digital camera myths and realities

This holiday 2009 primer offers tips on what and what not to look for in a compact digital camera.

Mark Russinovich on MinWin, the new core of Windows

The next version of Windows three years hence will likely build onto a significant architectural change implemented in Windows 7 and Server 2008 R2.

Android team updates 'Donut' and 'Eclair' SDKs

The Android SDK includes components which optimize app development for each version of the mobile operating system. Today, the 1.6 and 2.0 components got updates.

See ya later, WinMo: Microsoft's mobile strategy needs a reboot

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: Hands up if you're considering upgrading to a Windows phone for the holidays...Anybody?

Online advertising evolves away from display, toward interactive software

Marketing departments and agencies are increasingly establishing positions for "creative technologists" who can steer designers and developers toward platforms that enable direct connections with consumers.

Google begrudgingly adjusts news crawling for paid publishers

If publishers want to make readers pay for news content, and thereby drive down its popularity and Google ranking, the company says, they can just go right on ahead.

Fee or free? Murdoch, Huffington square off over the cost of Internet news

Participants in an FTC workshop yesterday witnessed the two extremes of the Web news publishing debate, still centered on the issue of long-term profitability.

Security firm: Windows patches not responsible for 'Black Screen of Death'

On second thought, maybe that access control list thingie with the lockdown something-or-rather didn't trigger an alleged, perhaps non-existent, pandemic.

Apple settles with Psystar except for 'circumvention devices'

The fracas with the Florida clone computer maker might have ended today had Apple not have muddled the issue over a cheap piece of Psystar software.