Apple: Fake Memo Didn't Come from Internal Server

By Nate Mook | Published May 18, 2007, 12:19 PM

Apple attempted to squash the confusion surrounding a fake memo published on AOL blog Engadget Wednesday, which claimed both the iPhone and Leopard were being delayed and temporarily led to a major drop in Apple stock. The company says the memo was not sent from its servers.

Instead, the fake memo was simply crafted to look like it came from Apple and contained the same wording that typically accompanies legitimate internal communication from the company's Bullet News system. The e-mail was then sent to a handful of employees, one of whom passed it to Engadget.

Within minutes, Apple's stock tumbled two percent, falling to an Intraday low of $103.42. This was after the stock opened the day up over $1.30 from its previous close. As it closed in on the end of the day's trading, the stock had still not managed to recoup all of its losses.

Apple lost four billion dollars in market capitalization in just six minutes.

Engadget claimed in an update to its original post that the e-mail "was an ACTUAL email distributed within Apple's internal email system to Apple employees." This statement led many to defend the blog's actions.

"I have to say that I, too, would have posted this news based on the source. The email was in fact sent from Apple’s email server to Apple employees and was then forwarded to Engadget from a trusted source," commented high-profile blogger Michael Arrington.

Even Jupiter Research vice president Michael Gartenberg -- a long proponent of getting the story right rather than first -- supported the site, stating that, "I don't if I would have acted differently than Ryan did. Engadget had a legitimate Apple email, coming from a source at Apple."

But Apple now says that the e-mail did not come from its internal email system, which indicates that a check of the message's headers could have revealed the hoax. The company did not say whether it would try to find the individual responsible for the fake memo.

AOL's Ryan Block, who manages Engadget and posted the original memo, apologized on the site late Thursday. In the posting, Block explained that the memo "by all appearances was a legitimate email from Apple corporate."

He also responded to the questionable point in the memo that said a press release had been issued to announce the delay of the iPhone and Leopard. Block believed a press release would come later, and the site would have been doing a "disservice to our readers" had it sat on the story until confirmation.

Due to the seeming manipulation in Apple's stock price, the SEC could take action, but would not confirm whether or not it was investigating the matter.

"The fact is that big blogs now have an incredible amount of power to move information quickly, and influence people more broadly than ever before. I’m not sure we (bloggers) understood quite how much influence we really had until yesterday," added Arrington.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

I'd love to see the headers on this email. I think some rather simple reading may have avoided this.

Score: 0

|

Blogs having GREAT influence means simply one thing: That you have a GREAT responsibility to get your story straight the FIRST time, rather than having to correct it, the SECOND time!

Score: 0

|

Didn't these bloggers want to have the same status as newspaper reporters? So treat them like one and prosecute them for stock manipulation.

Score: 0

|

Google Buzz: Another attempt to harness the content firehose

Similar to how Google successfully remolded RSS into a Google tool, the company now wants to remold Gmail into one big Google party

Success: Google's Nexus One shipping support line takes tech support questions

UPDATED Though the support line had been set up for shipping, it now appears Google personnel are happy to hear technical concerns.

Goodnight, moon: What I learned from a space shuttle

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: Can the tech sector learn a few lessons from the space program? Certainly, if you believe in learning from someone else's mistakes.

Netflix to FCC: NBCU + Comcast could bypass net neutrality

Weaning itself from the post office as its main means of video transfer, Netflix would like someone to ensure the Internet remains just as unencumbered.

Rhapsody to become an independent company

RealNetworks and Viacom subsidiary MTV Networks have begun the process of spinning off music service Rhapsody into an independent company.

Nvidia debuts new dynamically-switched graphics card technology

Today, Nvidia announced that its Optimus technology for GPU switching will soon be available in a handful of Asus notebooks.

Google lowers 'unusually high' early termination fee on Nexus One

Google has lowered the Nexus One's early termination fees which were twice as high as the norm.

Netgear and Ericsson introduce a mobile broadband hotspot with a twist

It's a mobile broadband hotspot, but it's for use in the home.

Report: Streaming video drove 72% global increase in mobile data consumption

A new study says streaming video is "the single most influential factor driving the need for increased mobile network capacity."

Stymied by continuing Nexus One 3G issues, Google blames the environment

If you're still afflicted with the 3G flip-flop trouble, then you might consider moving. That appears to be the only suggestion Google can give for now.

Wolfram|Alpha makes a strong argument for virtual keyboards

"Answer engine" Wolfram|Alpha has updated its iPhone/iPod Touch app, harnessing the strength of the virtual keyboard.