Apple Loses Appeal in Trade Secret Case

By Ed Oswald | Published May 30, 2006, 1:50 PM

In a crucial victory for both online journalists and bloggers, a California appeals court ruled Friday that Apple enthusiast site AppleInsider was entitled to the same protections as traditional journalists. The ruling overturns a previous verdict that would have put online writers at a serious disadvantage to their mainstream media counterparts.

The original ruling, handed down by California Superior Court Judge James Kleinberg in March of last year, stated that journalist protections not apply to the sites, as trade secrets were revealed in violation of state law.

"In no relevant respect do they appear to differ from a reporter or editor for a traditional business-oriented periodical who solicits or otherwise comes into possession of confidential internal information about a company," Justice Conrad Rushing wrote in the unanimous decision.

Rushing also said the court was not going to get involved in a debate over what would and would not be considered journalism. Furthermore, the law protects the newsgathering process, which the justices said AppleInsider did.

The appeals court found that the site was protected under California's shield law, as well as privacy of e-mails sent between the source and AppleInsider writers under federal law. In a statement, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which represented AppleInsider in its appeal, called the ruling a "huge win."

Apple was not returning press inquiries for comment on the case.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

I normally have great respect for Apple but how very very stupidly they have behaved.

Score: 0

|

So I guess that's what you get for worshiping overpriced products! A nice Apple iLawsuit. LOL Nice going Apple, that 4.7% of the market won't go up if you sue your loyal fans.

Score: 0

|

Suing their very own fans... way to go, Apple!

These are the people who follow and worship Apple like a cult. They show so much interest in whatever Apple is doing. And this is how Apple treats them. Sad...

Score: 0

|

So iApple has lost their iappeal in the court isystem. Oh well, I guess ithey need ianother source for information.

Score: 0

|

that was pretty iLame

Score: 0

|

- everyone's a critic-

Score: 0

|

That's iAppeal, iSystem, and iAnother.

Some people....

Score: 0

|

iCritic please

Score: 0

|

Yah, lol, when will their next iAppearance be in an iCourt?

Score: 0

|

What was the point of your post? Im not understanding.

Score: 0

|

He was not conforming to Apple's naming scheme.

I compounded bad humor with more bad humor.

What? Since when do two wrongs not make a right?

Score: 0

|

Google Chrome 4: Yes, it's fast, but is it usable?

As Betanews readers have responded to our stories about Chrome's JavaScript superiority...Does that mean we'd actually use this browser? Well...

Video: Netflix on PlayStation 3

Netflix has come to the PlayStation 3 via Blu-ray and BD-Live.

Verizon Wireless launches new Android, Chocolate, and ruggedized phones

The lower-priced Eris joins the Droid, while the Chocolate gets a touchscreen and more music playback.

Early sales figures for Windows 7 nicely high, but do we know why?

Fans of triple-digit surges in figures quoted by Betanews will love this one, as it appears Microsoft rediscovered how to pull off a software launch.

Myka announces its latest Linux-based 'net top box'

Myka's ION brings Boxee, XMBC, and much more to HDTVs.

What hath Mac wrought? A remembrance after a quarter-century

The reason there's a Macintosh today is not because of some brilliant flash of engineering genius, but because Apple had the audacity to learn from its mistakes.

Early build of Moblin 2.1 improves connectivity, but not device support

The Linux Foundation's Atom-centric OS yesterday received a major overhaul with the project release of Moblin 2.1 for netbooks and nettops.

The iPhone's China syndrome: Sales of 5,000 and climbing

There's actually a country where Apple's device is not a godsend, where sales can be measured in the dozens.

New European counterpart to FCC will ensure 'a more neutral net'

Late Thursday night, the ruling telecom administrators of the EU's member nations signed away their final authority to a new entity overseen by the EC.

Sophos study suggests Windows 7 UAC's default setting is self-defeating

Without any anti-virus installed, a Sophos test showed, User Account Control was only capable of thwarting just one malware package out of ten samples chosen.

Indiscreet tweet trips awareness of Web SSL vulnerability

A group of high-level security engineers had been making progress on thwarting a low-level threat to the Web, until somebody blurted it all out on Twitter.