British film board ready to review video games for younger audiences

By Michael Hatamoto | Published July 7, 2008, 4:25 PM

The agency responsible for classifying movies in the UK wants more power to review and pass judgment on video games intended for younger audiences, and is answering critics who claim it would create a monumental bureaucracy.

The British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) currently reviews 250 to 300 game titles, 500 to 600 movies, and at least 10,000 DVDs per year. Although movies are watched from start to finish, only the first five hours of a video game is played, with reviewers often times using cheat codes so material in later levels can be reviewed.

When reviewing movie titles, the BBFC evaluates its theme, language, nudity, sexual behavior level, violence, imitable techniques, horror, and drug and alcohol use. For the last six years, it's been rating films on a more granular scale than in the US, starting with the most general rating Uc (Universal children), then progressing to U, PG, 12A, 12 (no one under 12 can view or purchase), 15, 18, and the most restrictive R18 which is roughly equal to the informal "XXX" in the US.

The BBFC's role in rating some video games came to the public's attention after a report written by TV psychologist Dr. Tanya Byron indicated the group should be responsible for categorizing all video games to be sold to UK consumers. The agency hopes to have the Video Recordings Act lifted, or at least altered, so that a different group will rate only games that do not feature violence or sexual acts.

Cooke and the BBFC claim just a couple of people are responsible for rating video games under the Pan European Games Information (PEGI) group, which makes it difficult for them to accurately assess all games. The BBFC hopes to be able to handle all classifications for gamers 12 years and older, though today, it only classifies games that have an 18+ classification.

Electronic Arts and several other game studios have been vocal about the ratings debate, stating further BBFC control could lead to possible game delays as the organization isn't capable of reviewing more games. But Cooke said that although he has a team of 12 reviewers who would need to review an additional 300 to 500 games, they're capable of taking the added workload off of PEGI's shoulders.

"The trouble is that it is not clear who PEGI is," Cooke told the London Times. "Administration is handled by the Dutch film regulator, who subcontracts to a couple of blokes [the Video Standards Council] in Borehamwood."

The BBFC reportedly takes up to seven business days to review a game along with a fee close to $600. Game studios are worried that since the PEGI offers a European-wide classification, having to further assess games solely for the UK game market will push back game launch dates. Another concern is the possible analysis of all online media and downloadable game add-ons, which would also likely need to be reviewed by the BBFC before being released to gamers.

Game studios have very few legal options available to break free of the BBFC's growing power, with the organization continuing to affirm its willingness to work with game studios and parents.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Its a shame that not enough parent's assume the responsibility to simply be aware of what their kids do.

An objective and clear rating scale universally applied would be a nice tool for parents to use.

Score: 0

|

Agreed.

My only problem is with enforcement. The responsibility for enforcing compliance belongs with the parents and their children.

Most of these laws, including this one, make it illegal for a retailer to sell it to certain people. It's not the retailers job or responsibility to police their clientele.

Some kid ends up with a game without parents permission? Fine the parents. Not the retailer.

Score: 0

|

Should the same happen with obtaining alcohol underage or going to the cinema underage?

Policing the adults of the children is much harder than policing the retailer, so that's how it ends up.

I agree with you; it would be nice if the parents were fined, but it won't happen for the reason above.

Score: 0

|

Its called symbolism over substance.

Pass a law, s*** the responsibility, and go home smugly satisfied hat you did your share - even thought you have conveniently s***ed all responsibility from each person in their own sphere of influence to the proverbial "they".

And what you have is the modern liberal mentality in inaction.

But we can all sit around and wonder why its not working even though we passed a law saying it shouldn't ...Duh!

Score: 0

|

lmao..

I knew someone would try and push an irrelevant, unrelated example such as alcohol or guns.

Alcohol can cause severe physical damage if not controlled. You can not say the same of Video Games.

As for the cinema, my argument concerning the video games would apply there as well.

Truth be told, I even firmly believe that same argument applies to guns and alcohol. The retailer exists to sell merchandise, not to act as an enforcement agency for the government.

Kids kills someone with a gun? Mom and Dad take the heat.

Kid runs someone over driving underage? Parents lose the car, pay the fine, etc.

Kid is caught drinking by the cops underage? Parents pay the fine.

it would be nice if the parents were fined, but it won't happen for the reason above.

No excuse for forcing the retailer to take on the Federal and State's job of enforcing laws. They are not legally even allowed to enforce *any* law. (Or did I miss the part where we deputized all retailers?)

Score: 0

|

'A pivot from war to peace:' The AMD + Intel armistice, in their own words

An extraordinary day in technology history is recognized by two long-time rivals that mutually decided it's futile to fight anyplace else except the marketplace.

PS3, Xbox to soon get Twitter, Facebook integration

Both Microsoft's Xbox 360 and Sony's PlayStation 3 will integrate with Facebook in the near future.

Windows Marketplace for Mobile now available in browser, iTunes' App Store still not

You can now check out what Windows Marketplace for Mobile has to offer without a Windows Phone.

Microsoft damage control after marketer claims Win7 inspired by Mac

Have you ever said anything you wish you could take back? Ever? No? Not even once? Well then, you won't sympathize with a mid-level Microsoft manager today.

Blockbuster's way down, but poised for a comeback

Though it took a serious beating in 2009, Blockbuster CEO Jim Keyes says the company can turn it around.

iTunes Preview deson't go far enough to create Web-based option for store

Apple has rolled out iTunes Preview, a Web interface for browsing iTunes.

PDC 2009 Preview: The move to Office 2010 and Visual Studio 2010

The major focus of Microsoft's conference next week will likely be explaining why two pillars of its software sales strategy deserve to remain where they are.

Dell's first smartphone aids the Android onslaught

Longtime PC leader Dell has finally announced its Android-based smarphone.

After the Intel + AMD armistice: Do we really want a level playing field?

Scott Fulton On Point: One by one, the reasons for us to continue suspending the course toward open and fair competition in IT, are dropping like flies.

FLO TV launches pocketable, smartphone-like TVs

Qualcomm's FLO TV Personal Television made by HTC launches in retail today.

Google acquires Gizmo5, builds IP telephony portfolio

Google Voice today confirmed rumors that it would acquire IP telephony company Gizmo5