EC still holds Intel accountable even after AMD settlement

By Scott M. Fulton, III | Published November 12, 2009, 1:03 PM

Despite an historic resolution to AMD's and Intel's long-standing business practices and intellectual property disputes this morning, the official position of the European Commission -- which issued formal objections to, and fines for, Intel's alleged conduct last May -- is that nothing whatsoever has changed with regard to its ongoing prosecution of its Statement of Objections.

In a statement to Betanews this afternoon, EC spokesperson Jonathan Todd said: "The Commission takes note that Intel and AMD have settled all their litigation and that Intel is paying AMD compensation of $1.25 billion. Intel has an ongoing obligation to comply with the Commission's May 2009 Decision and with EU antitrust law. The Commission continues to vigorously monitor Intel's compliance with its obligations under the May 2009 Decision."

Although AMD is likely to continue cooperating with regulators worldwide, its active participation in their efforts is likely to subside, but not yet completely.

"The regulatory investigations and enforcement actions around the world are conducted by sovereign governments pursuant to law and their mandates to protect competitive processes and consumer value," said AMD Executive Vice President for Legal Affairs Tom McCoy this morning. "So the regulators will do what they are going to do; and what we would say is that, from our perspective, we are withdrawing, obviously, from all pending litigation. We will be withdrawing all complaints that have been lodged with regulatory agencies, and if asked, we will say that the agreement, to a great extent, resolves outstanding disputes between AMD and Intel under the antitrust laws. There are some exceptions, there are some practices that we believe are exclusionary, that we will, under the agreement, there are a narrow set which we will continue to advocate to the regulators should be addressed for the health of the industry; and Intel will have its own point of view of that, of course. So the regulatory agencies still have a role to play, but from our perspective, this agreement significantly resolves our concerns."

From Intel's perspective, all of the regulatory concerns that governments may have stem from AMD's original civil complaint. And now that that's over, Intel believes, the rest of it all should follow.

"In terms of regulators, I think in general, all of these comments that have been coming from regulators, and actions, have been as a result of the complaints between these two private parties," said Intel CEO Paul Otellini this morning. "Now that the issues between the private parties are settled, I think that should provide some degree of comfort for the regulators, at least in terms of our behaviors and how we're going to compete in the marketplace, and so forth. Beyond that, they may have their other concerns in areas like pricing, as we've mentioned, that we may still want to them and they may want to talk to us about."

Endpoint analyst Roger Kay later pressed the Intel executives for further clarity, including with regard to the New York Attorney General's antitrust complaint, filed last week.

"In the places in the world where AMD had complaints against us, those will be withdrawn," responded Intel Executive Vice President for Legal Affairs Andy Bryant. "In places where governments around the world were asking us questions, those will continue on. Actually the EU appeal will continue on...We are having discussions with the [US] FTC; currently, there are other countries in the world who have asked us questions, we will still continue to talk to them, answer their questions. And of course, we have the New York Attorney General situation to deal with."

This prompted a Fortune Magazine correspondent to ask whether A-G Andrew Cuomo's complaint -- which contained never-before-public e-mails from Intel execs, including Otellini, as evidence of improper conduct -- led Intel to conclude it must settle now with AMD to avoid embarrassment.

Otellini responded first by revealing that settlement talks with AMD actually began last April, before the EC's Statement of Objections. In fact, it's conceivable that had the EC suspended its operations for another month, it might have discovered it had less to complain about.

With respect to Mr. Cuomo's filed complaint, Otellini added, "On some of the statements in there that were attributed to me, yeah, I wrote some of those, at least the ones I remember. On the other hand, many of those documents are taken broadly out of context. When the full nature of the e-mails is exposed, I think that you'll see there's another way to interpret some of these statements. Remember, there were 200 million pages of documents produced, and these were four or five snippets out of 200 million pages. So we're anxious to talk about our side of the story and show our other halves of e-mails, and so forth, as we go forward."

Betanews has shared some of Otellini's statements with Attorney General Cuomo's office, and we may expect a response from him later in the day.

Add a Comment

You must be logged in to post comments.

View comments by with a score of at least

Did anyone honestly think this was going to change with what has just happened?

Score: 0

|

No, of course.

Why a decision between privates will render obsolete an investigation by a government?

Score: 0

|

Especially not when there are American monies ripe for the taking by the EC.

Score: 0

|

PDC 2009: What have we learned this week?

There was the freebie that no one will forget, the heebie-jeebies courtesy of Scott Guthrie, and a teensy bit clearer picture of how this cloud thingie should work.

Live report: Will Google Chrome OS change Linux?

The mysteries of just what Chrome OS is, and how much of an operating system it truly is, may be resolved today.

PDC 2009: Microsoft cares about Web browser performance

The effort to give users of the world's dominant Web browser the impression of quality, is a personal one for the man who leads that battle.

Nokia re-affirms its commitment to Symbian, sort of

Maemo won't necessarily be replacing Symbian in the Nokia N-Series, but that's definitely a place where it will be found.

E-book readers will be in short supply this holiday season

E-readers are hot this year, and a lot of compelling new products have been released, but are there enough electrophoretic displays to go around?

Sony looks to finally open a single storefront for downloads

Sony has had many different download portals for movies, music, e-books, and games, and now it's looking to make a single shop for all of it.

Tuning out the tablet: Time to give the endless speculation a rest

Wide Angle Zoom: Wishing and hoping and thinking and praying....won't put an iTablet on the market.

Five improvements for IT managers in 2010

If businesses are to improve their efficiency for next year, they need to stop and reassess the basic tenets of their job.

AOL's spinoff from Time Warner to shed 2,500 jobs

As AOL moves toward become an independent company again, it will cut nearly a third of its workforce.

Gartner: SMS-based money transfer will be bigger than mobile browsing, search

Gartner issues its predictions for the 10 things our phones will be doing in 2012.

Don't forget to upgrade to Firefox 3.6 beta 3 today

Mozilla has released the latest beta its Firefox 3.6 browser software, just over one week after beta 2.