Firefox 3.5 vs. Chrome 3 Showdown, Round 3: Finding a place for more tabs

By Scott M. Fulton, III | Published July 7, 2009, 5:26 PM


Download Google Chrome for Windows Beta 3.0.191.3 from Fileforum now.

Banner: Special series

With Web pages having evolved into Web sites and moving on to become Web applications, we find ourselves frequently revisiting the question of what a Web browser tab should represent. In researching a topic for multiple stories during the course of a day, I often find myself with as many as a hundred tabs open at one time. And yes, I try to keep them in some kind of order, which is never easy; and when the browser crashes (as it still often does), recovering all those open tabs is becoming more difficult, it seems, as time goes on.

Improving the way one organizes tabs is part of the entire value proposition for Google Chrome; besides its impressive architecture under the hood, tab management is one of the few front-end features Google sought to perfect from the very beginning. The idea behind Google's approach to tabs is this: Perhaps in this evolving Web landscape, a tab should be whatever the user designates or needs it to be at the time. So if the user should decide it should go in a window or outside of a window or floating around on its own, for whatever reason, Chrome should enable those options. And it should enable as many options as possible.

Does that mean those options are self-evident or self-explanatory? Not at all. In typical Google fashion, unless you're reading some sort of comic-book-styled sales brochure -- or this particular article -- you have to either stumble upon these options for yourself, or read an article like this one. It's strange to note that of the major Windows Web browsers produced today, only Mozilla Firefox and Opera render their pages in typical window devices -- even Microsoft Internet Explorer 8 uses a non-standard window. For Google Chrome, this means that each tab must serve double-duty as a Web page's title bar. That actually may be a problem in cases where titles run long -- e.g., news sites whose names fall first, followed by the headline. You can still point to each tab, and in a moment see a tooltip with the full title -- a slight inconvenience, if any at all, but also an indication of one of the problems all browser architects must face. Whereas an application is easily identifiable by its icon, a Web page's icon may denote its publisher but not its purpose.

So if you don't mind your desktop looking like…well, like mine at times, then Chrome 3 presents you with a way to work out where Web pages or applications should be arranged and how they should work. While you can still drag and drop a Chrome window anywhere on the desktop and create any number of windows for collecting more tabs, you can drag a tab away from one window and into another or onto the desktop by itself (thus creating a new window). And the beta of Chrome is experimenting with a system perhaps inspired by, or inspiring (depending upon whom you ask), the Aero Snap feature of Windows 7. Though Beta 3.0.190.1 had some trouble with this feature, Beta 3.0.191.3 released this morning appeared, in Betanews tests, to have fixed its troubles:

Experiments with dragging a tab outside the browser window, here in Google Chrome 3.• When you drag a Chrome tab (as opposed to a window) toward the center of the edge of the desktop, an animated symbol pops up representing the projected placement of the tab's new window on the desktop if you were to release the mouse button. If you leave this symbol alone and release the button, then the new window will be created at the mouse pointer location. But if you continue dragging on top of this symbol and release there, then the new window will be opened as indicated by the symbol. For example, if you drag to the bottom (just above the taskbar), you'll see a symbol showing a window that hugs the bottom and that's half-height, leaving the top open. If you drag to the left, you'll see a symbol for a window that hugs the left edge, that's full-height and half-width. It's a little different than Microsoft's method, introduced in Windows 7, of "bumping" the edge of the desktop, and it takes an extra step, but it's certainly sensible. I've said before that I really like this feature in Windows 7, and I must admit to really liking Google Chrome's interpretation of it.

Experiments with dragging a tab outside the browser window, here in Google Chrome 3.• When you drag a Chrome tab toward the center of the outside edge of another Chrome window that has room alongside for a new neighbor, another animated symbol pops up depicting the relative location of the new window if you were to release the mouse button. This way, you can create a new window beside an existing one, hugging its edge. For example, if you drag an open tab toward the center of the left edge of an open Chrome window, the symbol will show two windows beside one another. You have to touch this symbol (bringing it from transparency to the forefront) and release the mouse button to snap the new window to the edge of the existing one.

• Inserting an open tab into any open Chrome window, even if it only has one tab open, and releasing the mouse button, results in that tab being reinserted in the open window at that location. This is how you expect things to work, but up until today's release of build 3.0.190.1, that's been a problem for Chrome.

While Google has been working since last year to show up Mozilla in the functionality department, you can't help but think this time around, it can't resist the opportunity to one-up Microsoft.

Next: What helps Firefox in one way, holds it back in another…

1 | 2 | Next Page →

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

did you know you can drop firefox tabs into chrome?, only works with firefox 3.0 not 3.5 atm
and that if you close a tab your form data is saved like i just did when i accidentally quit the betanews tab

btw chrome updates itself in the background, so win, with firefox you have to WATCH IT update :p

Score: 0

|

One of the best tools for organizing tabs in Firefox is Tree Style Tab

https://addons.mozilla.o...n-US/firefox/addon/5890

It permits tabs to be organized vertically, which is perfect for widescreen monitors, and of course as a tree, tabs can be nested, as well as easily moved and closed.

The only problem right now is there is an incompatibility issue in FF3.5 between Tab Mix Plus and Tree Style Tab, where new tabs opened from an existing tab are opened in the wrong location, but I'm sure this will be resolved soon.

In fact, I'm thinking of dropping TMP soon and going only with Tree Style Tab, as it's that convenient.

-- Drew

Score: 1

|

I dropped the bloated TMP (after using it for years) and stuck with Tree Style Tabs and it has made a HUGE difference. I just install a handful of lightweight and essential addons to fill in for TMP:

Tab Wheel Scroll
https://addons.mozilla.o...n-US/firefox/addon/6501

LastTab (a lot better than Ctrl-Tab addon)
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/112

Session Manager
https://addons.mozilla.o...n-US/firefox/addon/2324

Tabloc
https://addons.mozilla.o...-US/firefox/addon/12536

I no longer have to remember the laundry list of settings for TMP on every fresh Firefox install.

Score: 1

|

welcome and thank you for mercy

Score: 0

|

Totally unnecessary stuff (to me at least)...

Here's what I've found:

Page loads: I view a *lot* of forums and comments sections where I constantly refresh. Firefox reloads faster. It seems to pull images and such from cache, only downloading new or changed content. Chrome seems to pull *everything* from the server regardless. This takes longer.

Firefox Wins. If anyone knows a way to configure Chrome to reload from cache unless a change is detected, please let me know. There are no options for cache handling in the options window.

Session Management: I restore previous tabs, and frequently go back a session or two (especially when multiple windows were involved). The session management in Firefox *exists* and can be added to with a plethora of plug ins that extend the functionality greatly. Chrome has *one* option for restoring past tabs or a list of tabs *on startup only*.

Firefox wins.

Updates: Firefox updates consistently, but forces you to watch it do so when you launch the browser. Chrome updates consistently and you never even know it happened unless you watch the "about" window. Sure, there's a program running int he background to do this, but I have yet to find a system that bogs down because of this.

Chrome wins.

Now, I can live with the "reload on startup only" Chrome gives me if I can find a workaround for the page-(re)load issue. If Chrome has this and I haven't found it yet or gets it soon, I will ditch Firefox in a heartbeat.

Score: 0

|

For late nighters, Google has announce it will be producing an OS.This will be interesting to see how this pplays out along side a possible DOJ investigation.

Score: 0

|

I still think Chrome should've won round 1 (Or at least gotten more testing). I still can't reproduce the results you found relating to cookies being stored until reboot with Incognito mode. As soon as I close the Incognito window, and open a new one, everything is gone, shopping carts are empty. Like others said, you may have still had a Chrome process running in the background and not known it.

Score: 0

|

FF 3.5 tab management is one of my least favorite features. It is extremely unintuitive to slide open tabs behind a greyed out arrow that typically indicates inactivity...

Score: 0

|

I have to disagree. I, finally, like the way new tabs are opened in FF. By clicking the square with the plus sign. Great move, very convenient and like IE which had FF beat in this area.

Score: 0

|

PDC 2009: What have we learned this week?

There was the freebie that no one will forget, the heebie-jeebies courtesy of Scott Guthrie, and a teensy bit clearer picture of how this cloud thingie should work.

Live report: Will Google Chrome OS change Linux?

The mysteries of just what Chrome OS is, and how much of an operating system it truly is, may be resolved today.

PDC 2009: Microsoft cares about Web browser performance

The effort to give users of the world's dominant Web browser the impression of quality, is a personal one for the man who leads that battle.

Nokia re-affirms its commitment to Symbian, sort of

Maemo won't necessarily be replacing Symbian in the Nokia N-Series, but that's definitely a place where it will be found.

E-book readers will be in short supply this holiday season

E-readers are hot this year, and a lot of compelling new products have been released, but are there enough electrophoretic displays to go around?

Sony looks to finally open a single storefront for downloads

Sony has had many different download portals for movies, music, e-books, and games, and now it's looking to make a single shop for all of it.

Tuning out the tablet: Time to give the endless speculation a rest

Wide Angle Zoom: Wishing and hoping and thinking and praying....won't put an iTablet on the market.

Five improvements for IT managers in 2010

If businesses are to improve their efficiency for next year, they need to stop and reassess the basic tenets of their job.

AOL's spinoff from Time Warner to shed 2,500 jobs

As AOL moves toward become an independent company again, it will cut nearly a third of its workforce.

Gartner: SMS-based money transfer will be bigger than mobile browsing, search

Gartner issues its predictions for the 10 things our phones will be doing in 2012.

Don't forget to upgrade to Firefox 3.6 beta 3 today

Mozilla has released the latest beta its Firefox 3.6 browser software, just over one week after beta 2.