Google Click Fraud Settlement Hits Snag

By Ed Oswald | Published May 12, 2006, 11:29 AM

Lawyers representing several Internet search advertisers who use Google's AdWords service have filed suit hoping to block a proposed $90 million settlement over allegations of click fraud. The plaintiffs claim that the settlement does not adequately compensate those affected.

"Advertisers must decide: take the pennies offered by Google and be happy with the status quo or opt out and pursue legal restitution through a lawsuit," Dylan Pollard, a Los Angeles-based plaintiffs' click fraud attorney, said earlier this week. "Either way, they don't have much time to decide."

On Thursday, they made the decision to file suit in the same Arkansas court that the original settlement was reached. A judge is set to hear arguments in a two-day hearing July 24 to decide on whether to approve the settlement.

Click fraud occurs when a person displaying advertising on their Web pages either manually or automatically clicks a link repeatedly in order to generate revenue. The advertiser is then forced to pay for these false leads.

While Google does not directly participate, the plaintiffs argued that the company does too little to prevent it from occurring. The settlement gave $60 million in advertising credits, and a staggering $30 million to be used for lawyer fees. No cash would be given as part of the payment.

Pollard has teamed up with another click fraud lawyer, Shawn Khorrami, to start a Web site that helps Google advertisers opt out of the proposed settlement. It is hoped that enough plantiffs would opt out that it would cause the judge to throw out the initial settlement.

"To try to obtain compensation from past click fraud abuses with Google, advertisers need to be pro-active. To start the process, they must opt out of the proposed settlement," Kohorrami argued.

Furthermore, Google could legally get away with paying as little as a half percent of total losses. Thus, a $10,000 click-fraud loss could theoretically be settled for as little as a $50 advertising coupon.

Google called the lawsuit inappropriate, and questioned its motives. "We question if this lawsuit may be motivated more by the quest for attorneys' fees than pursuit of what's best for class members," the company said in a statement.

Comments

We at http://www.clickdefense.com are vigorously analyzing client’s data to show incidence of likely click fraud. Most clients want a 3rd party look at their data to show any PCF (potential click fraud) missed by Google. Google only sees clicks that are subject to their billing. Clicks collected from other search engines showing identical IP addresses or same "out of market" area can show otherwise innocent looking Google clicks as PCF. We use many different filters to enable us to identify PCF. Yes, we do have attorneys (some of the nation’s best I might add) lined up to help our clients get refunds that are rightfully theirs. http://www.clickfraudlegal.com/

Score: 0

|

if you would like to opt out or talt to an lawyer go to this link www.clickfraud-legal-center.com

Score: 0

|

Gimme mo' money!

Score: 0

|

odd, i mean, i know many who complain click fraud did not happen yet they were acused of it....

would making the door harder to get through be safer for people trying to get in the door?

poor google, they need to work on this

Score: 0

|

I didn't join the class settlement. How do I get the credit? Any links anywhere?

Score: 0

|

I don't think you can get the credit if you didn't join the class action.

Score: 0

|

If you think you have a considerable amount due you, you can opt out of the class action and file an individual suit as many are doing.
Ck this site: http://www.clickfraudlegal.com/

Score: 0

|

If you think you have a considerable amount due you, you can opt out of the class action and file an individual suit as many are doing.
Ck this site: http://www.clickfraudlegal.com/

Score: 0

|

WTF! Inadequate.. Are you kidding? Yeah, because they lawyers don't get enough cut! Those greedy bas****s.

Score: 0

|

Can Linux do BitLocker better than Windows 7?

Betanews kicks off a new series with a look at how the Linux operating system's FDE stacks up against BitLocker, the Windows feature that today commands a $120 premium.

Firefox 3.5: The need for speed

This has been the big payoff week for Mozilla's developers, who worked overtime to squeeze out the last drop of performance from their new JavaScript engine.

'GeoHot' gets a shower, cleans up nice, reveals new iPhone 3G S jailbreak

Either puberty has been very kind to the author of the new 'Purple Ra1n' jailbreak tool, or George Hotz may also have some adequate Photoshop skills.

What's Next: Obama gives 'Einstein' the go-ahead, while China gives 'Green Dam' a thumbs-down

Plus: If you put up a Web site and name it after you and you're a federal judge, you might not want a bunch of weird nudity hanging around on it.

Why would Windows 7 customers spend $120 more for BitLocker?

For pre-orders from now until July 11, Microsoft is offering the Windows 7 Professional SKU for a very steep discount. So why invest in Ultimate?

Geeks vs. journalists: A tale of two worldviews

Recovery with Angela Gunn Why geeks think most mainstream journalism is flaky, and why the mainstream thinks geeks are trying to kill them. (They're both right.)

Fire in downtown Seattle data center knocks out businesses, online services

Small fire has global impact with payment centers, city services down.

Hybrid satellite cell phones aren't far off

The first satellite in Terrestar's hybrid cellular/satellite phone network has been launched.

SMS could be a critical iPhone vulnerability, says white-hat hacker

Mac hacker Charlie Miller knows how to get into your iPhone.

Will Oracle's Java-based Fusion middleware 'fuse' with Java?

Now that Oracle has acquired Sun Microsystems, Java developers and supporters are wondering when Oracle will formally welcome Java into the family.

All together now: iPhone and Palm Pre, likely to both grace O2's UK portfolio

European wireless network operator O2 has reportedly reached a deal to exclusively carry the Palm Pre in the UK. O2,...

Vista's dead: Microsoft kills an OS and no one cares

Carmi Levy: Wide Angle Zoom Can you kill an operating system? Microsoft is about to find out.

Kantaris Media Player 0.5.7

July 3 - 5:34 PM ET

Wine 1.1.25

July 3 - 5:30 PM ET

ChrisTV Online! Free 4.00

July 3 - 5:22 PM ET

glu 1.0.19 RC1

July 3 - 5:11 PM ET

Website-Watcher 5.1.0 Beta 10

July 3 - 1:20 PM ET