Google India could be ordered to break one blogger's anonymity

By Tim Conneally | Published August 15, 2008, 4:21 PM

A construction equipment company in Mumbai, India, has asked that country's high court to order Google India to disclose the identity of "Toxic Writer," a blogger who made defamatory remarks about its mining project in Mozambique.

According to the original complaint filed by Gremach Infrastructure Equipments and Projects Ltd., the ninth paragraph of a blog entry entitled "toxic fumes" contained defamatory material that amounted to a smear campaign against it. However, because the blog post was taken down on an interim order from the Bombay High Court, the actual text is unavailable and even some cached copies cannot be retrieved.

Still, some cached replies contain information as to the subject matter within the contentious blog.

An unnamed source from Gremach has been quoted as suspecting "corporate rivalry behind the hate campaign." Indeed, the blog post began: "Here's what somebody from the steel sector has sent me: As an employee of an Indian steel maker using the blast furnace route, we too are keenly watching the developments in Mozambique in order to secure our..."

The post reportedly goes on to describe an investor whose investments were tied up in Germach's rapidly falling stock, as the manufacturer allegedly diverted funds to a company called Austral Coke. Germach's stock price has dropped in value from Rs 500 ($11.90) to Rs 86 ($2.00) per share as of closing bell yesterday.

A reply entitled, "Gremach Investor Don't Fear" posted by a user named Chinu on February 11, 2008, reads in its entirety:

I am Employee of Gremach Infrastructure. I bought the shares at Rs. 440. But i don't have any Fear because technically stock is very Strong. Mr Toxic Writer we have already launched Police FIR against your mail , Your Computer and your ID is access by Cyber Crime Department. Now your time is finished now it's a game of 5 days.

This reply corroborates reports that Gremach had first contacted Mumbai Police to find the blogger's identity before taking legal action. Google was given four weeks to disclose the name of the blogger in the order issued by Justice Dhananjay Chandrachud, but has yet to do so. The case will be heard again within the next two weeks.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Google will cave in and provide the info they want. Why? They've done it on the past, and that doesn't even cover the censorship that Google gave their blessing to when some of the iffy dictatorships flexed their muscle.

Score: 0

|

"Do no Evil"

It's funny how once google became a public corp that motto isn't even enforceable by them anymore. They are at the whim of their shareholders and law enforcement bureaus now.

Score: 0

|

Funny how some crimes can't be ejudicated across international lines but some can. Murderers can escape back to their home country and take years (if ever) to be extradited, but a blog post can force an entire corporation to spill their guts and forfeit privacy? Wow. I hope Google doesn't give in.

Score: 0

|

'A pivot from war to peace:' The AMD + Intel armistice, in their own words

An extraordinary day in technology history is recognized by two long-time rivals that mutually decided it's futile to fight anyplace else except the marketplace.

PS3, Xbox to soon get Twitter, Facebook integration

Both Microsoft's Xbox 360 and Sony's PlayStation 3 will integrate with Facebook in the near future.

Windows Marketplace for Mobile now available in browser, iTunes' App Store still not

You can now check out what Windows Marketplace for Mobile has to offer without a Windows Phone.

Microsoft damage control after marketer claims Win7 inspired by Mac

Have you ever said anything you wish you could take back? Ever? No? Not even once? Well then, you won't sympathize with a mid-level Microsoft manager today.

Blockbuster's way down, but poised for a comeback

Though it took a serious beating in 2009, Blockbuster CEO Jim Keyes says the company can turn it around.

iTunes Preview deson't go far enough to create Web-based option for store

Apple has rolled out iTunes Preview, a Web interface for browsing iTunes.

PDC 2009 Preview: The move to Office 2010 and Visual Studio 2010

The major focus of Microsoft's conference next week will likely be explaining why two pillars of its software sales strategy deserve to remain where they are.

Dell's first smartphone aids the Android onslaught

Longtime PC leader Dell has finally announced its Android-based smarphone.

After the Intel + AMD armistice: Do we really want a level playing field?

Scott Fulton On Point: One by one, the reasons for us to continue suspending the course toward open and fair competition in IT, are dropping like flies.

FLO TV launches pocketable, smartphone-like TVs

Qualcomm's FLO TV Personal Television made by HTC launches in retail today.

Google acquires Gizmo5, builds IP telephony portfolio

Google Voice today confirmed rumors that it would acquire IP telephony company Gizmo5