In praise of Windows Media Center
By Angela Gunn | Published January 15, 2009, 9:42 AM
Microsoft showed off developments on Windows Media Center last week at CES. Despite the Ballmer bluster, despite the inexorable march of Microsoft to seize control of all your screens, something important needs to be said.
Specifically: Not bad, Microsoft.
We've come a long way from the schadenfreud-a-riffic 2005 CES keynote, when WMC crashed during Bill Gates's keynote demo. (We've even come a long way from November, when Microsoft hauled a group of writers and bloggers out to Redmond to talk about WMC for Windows 7 but showed us mainly screen shots.) Our brief visit with Windows Media Center was an encouraging look at a product that's gotten smarter, more flexible, and more fun to know with age.
Some of the charm may simply mean that Media Center's edging out from under Vista's long black shadow. Some of it may also be mounting excitement over Media Center Extender turning up in more television sets; as the WMC interface becomes an in-the-gears option for interacting with the set, it's easy to fall in love with the things Microsoft has gotten right.
In Microsoft fashion, the company has accomplished this in part by pinpointing and exploiting the mistakes of its competition. If anyone in the US is a fan of their cable provider's channel guide, check that person for deer ticks -- simply put, cable providers know you're captive and they do to you as they will. And the experience is horrid. Microsoft, on the other hand, may often behave as if its consumers are captive, but in the case of WMC, at the very least, it treats those captives with kindness. It's touching.
Literally, it's touching -- one of the advances in the 7 version of WMC is the advent of touch gestures to get around guides and move through menus. For instance, multitouch content-skimming within a music collection managed via WMC proves a lot more appealing for me than using Cover Flow, the analogous activity within iTunes. It may be that the WMC demo had enough artists represented to trigger the excellent Turbo Scroll option (about 200, the presenter estimated), but I felt I was getting a far more satisfying glance at the system through Microsoft's eyes, and far more intuitively.
It seems too that Microsoft's picking up some smarts about how people use their collections. Playlists are better supported, and the ability to "pin" an album indicates that Redmond understands that sometimes there's something you just need to hear over and over for a while. And were I carrying a Windows Mobile device or the Zune, the ability to sync recorded TV content to either of those device would be powerful stuff for those addicted to DVR-style time shifting.
Best of all for the inveterate video-scrounger, Microsoft suspects that you don't want to have to figure out whether the show you want to pull from the Internet is on abc.go.com, hulu.com, or joesbarandvideo.com -- you just want to watch it, and it's WMC's job to figure out where and how. It does. Just like that. I may never be in the market for a Zune, but I can also cheerfully forget everything I've taught myself about digging up video online if Microsoft's going to do it so smoothly on my behalf.
Microsoft reps have a habit of talking up their big wins, such as their success in bringing Olympics coverage -- meaning coverage of all the events and not just those NBC programmers felt would draw the biggest ratings, to the WMC masses. They tell me that the average viewer of that Olympics coverage spent 5-6 hours watching, and that's astonishing (and, for users such as the Seattle-area parent who got to watch her son compete in judo at o'dark-thirty thanks to the service, kind of wonderful).
But the real wins for Windows Media Center are going to be much more subtle: A convert to the elegant programming guide here, a please-don't-make-me-search-ABC's-site-again refugee there. It's not a bad vision of the post-Vista world, not at all.

WMC has come a long way and 7MC looks to be the best iteration yet. It still needs improvement however. I'm not sure where the author is getting her information but Hulu.com, abc.com, etc. content is not available in Media Center. At least nothing more than previews. And it certainly isn't available on extenders unless the company that produces it is providing that content outside of the MC UI.
We've used media center in our home since 2K5 edition in XP and have never looked back. I blog and podcast about media center and consider myself an evangelist. However, it still needs more and MS needs to listen to the community before they get passed up completely by competitors like Boxee and SageTV.
Score: 0
|crazy that people still get their media from broadcast medium.
Score: 0
|If Microsoft is serious about WMC they MUST push for hardware that can interact with 2 way cable cards or tru2way, and they cannot be OEM only parts. And they need to stop bowing to cable companies wishes and allowing them to illegally prevent the recording of a TV show.
Score: 1
|I think WMC is awesome and in Windows 7 is even better. The only thing I wish is that there were more choices for CableCards. It sucks that you can not build your own PC and have support for CableCards. Also, for premade computers (Dell, HP, Sony, ETC...) they should offer more with CableCard support then what they currently offer.
Score: 0
|WMC7 isn't a giant leap from VMC with TV Pack 2008, which was great except for poorly support wtv format combined with broken public API needed for commercial skippers (has this been fixed in WMC7?). A lot of it is just simple UI polish added to TV Pack 2008 (not that this is a bad thing). It is encouraging to see the devs at MS finally improve upon the embarassing music end of VMC.
Score: -1
|We http://leapyearphoto.com have been using MCE for years now as a great way to display our photography at weddings and other events. It really shines there and I could not live without it in our living room. I am very impressed with the improvments added to Windows7.
Score: 0
|Who needs WMC when you have Boxee for Windows\Linux\Mac for Free (based on XBMC\XMBC) ?
Score: -8
|Go. Away.
Score: 0
|I could be wrong but Boxee doesn't have dvr capabilities, does it?
Score: -1
|have you ever used Media Center? I have used several free/open source alternative, they don't compare.
Score: 0
|Never ran in to the NO RECORD flag with Vista and WMC. Everything has recorded just fine. What I have run in to is a flag that prevents the show from being burned to a DVD AFTER it has been recorded. Flagged or not I can watch it on my HTPC.
Not saying I like it, but that is the way it works.
Score: 0
|My question is, did they get rid of the support for the "no record flag" that was added in the Vista version ?
If not, I'll stick to my TIVO.
Score: 0
|Windows MCE has been a good program since XP MCE2005 with the rollup pack. I was a little disappointed in the Vista interface but it has since been cleaned up again in Win7. The best use of MC is with a TV tuner card so you can use the EXCELLENT DVR. Even if you don't have a tuner there is some great online content (watched a foo fighters concert last night). If you have it and don't use it, you really need to check it out.
Score: 0
|