MS Claims EU Antitrust Malfeasance

By Ed Oswald | Published February 15, 2006, 12:01 PM

Microsoft called the European Union on the carpet Wednesday, arguing that the EU was ignoring "critical evidence in its haste to attack the company’s compliance." The statement was part of a 75-page response to charges that the company was not complying with a 2004 European Commission antitrust decision.

The company was mandated to respond to a December statement of objections, the EU's version of a formal indictment. The company was threatened with fines of 2 million euros per day for non-compliance.

Hundreds of employees worked for 30,000 hours to create some 12,000 pages of technical documents, Microsoft said. The company has also agreed to provide 500 hours of technical support and opened up its source code to those who obtain a license to view it.

To back up its claim, a 49-page report from five computer science professors in the United Kingdom and Germany was sent along with the response.

"We believe that [the interoperability information] has provided complete and accurate information, to the extent that this can be reasonably achieved, covering protocols, dependencies and implicit knowledge," the report read.

Microsoft further accused the EU of ignoring evidence and denying the company due process in its decisions. It complained that it was only given several weeks to make requested changes to technical documents when the commission had the documents for several months.

The Redmond company also claimed that the EU did not review changes Microsoft had made to technical documents before issuing its statement of objections.

"When the Commission issued its Statement of Objections on December 21, 2005, the Commission and its experts had not even bothered to read the most recent version of those documents which Microsoft had made available on December 15, 2005," Microsoft's filing states.

As of press time, the European Commission had not responded publicly to Microsoft's filing.

Comments

YAWN...

When is Microsoft going to pack it in? They got where they are by cheating every other software company on earth. The bill is now due, just like the tobaccoo companies, pay it and go out of business already!!

Score: 0

|

If you're waiting for Microsoft to go out of business, you'll be waiting quite a while.

Score: 0

|

Wow, this is a lot of "he said, he did" taddling. Both sides seem to be blaming the other, and the media exploits this only further due to their source of information.

In order for both to save face, they need to resolve it very quickly.

Score: 0

|

Eeeeeeewwwwwwwwwwww.

Score: 0

|

Ever noticed... if you say EU real fast it sounds like "Ewww"?

Score: 0

|

Ever noticed...if you wrap your arm around your head and shove your fingers up your nose it hurts?

...probably why no-one does it. ;P

Score: 0

|

Europe... haha. They try so hard...

Score: 0

|

Or...

They're so very trying....

Score: 0

|

Do, or do not... there is no try.

Score: 0

|

You must unlearn what you have learned.

Seriously... All this EU stuff is beginning to confuse me. Hasn't Microsoft ALREADY complied? O.o

Score: 0

|

Sick have we become...(think we got the Star Wars Fever)

Nope, not according to the Ewwww...er, the EU:
http://www.tgdaily.com/2...crosoft_missed_deadline/

They more than complied IMO, but the socialists in the EU would disagree.

Score: 0

|

To put it mildly...

Score: 0

|

Go socialists!

Score: 0

|

gg Microsoft!

Score: 0

|

Can Linux do BitLocker better than Windows 7?

Betanews kicks off a new series with a look at how the Linux operating system's FDE stacks up against BitLocker, the Windows feature that today commands a $120 premium.

Firefox 3.5: The need for speed

This has been the big payoff week for Mozilla's developers, who worked overtime to squeeze out the last drop of performance from their new JavaScript engine.

'GeoHot' gets a shower, cleans up nice, reveals new iPhone 3G S jailbreak

Either puberty has been very kind to the author of the new 'Purple Ra1n' jailbreak tool, or George Hotz may also have some adequate Photoshop skills.

What's Next: Obama gives 'Einstein' the go-ahead, while China gives 'Green Dam' a thumbs-down

Plus: If you put up a Web site and name it after you and you're a federal judge, you might not want a bunch of weird nudity hanging around on it.

Why would Windows 7 customers spend $120 more for BitLocker?

For pre-orders from now until July 11, Microsoft is offering the Windows 7 Professional SKU for a very steep discount. So why invest in Ultimate?

Geeks vs. journalists: A tale of two worldviews

Recovery with Angela Gunn Why geeks think most mainstream journalism is flaky, and why the mainstream thinks geeks are trying to kill them. (They're both right.)

Fire in downtown Seattle data center knocks out businesses, online services

Small fire has global impact with payment centers, city services down.

Hybrid satellite cell phones aren't far off

The first satellite in Terrestar's hybrid cellular/satellite phone network has been launched.

SMS could be a critical iPhone vulnerability, says white-hat hacker

Mac hacker Charlie Miller knows how to get into your iPhone.

Will Oracle's Java-based Fusion middleware 'fuse' with Java?

Now that Oracle has acquired Sun Microsystems, Java developers and supporters are wondering when Oracle will formally welcome Java into the family.

All together now: iPhone and Palm Pre, likely to both grace O2's UK portfolio

European wireless network operator O2 has reportedly reached a deal to exclusively carry the Palm Pre in the UK. O2,...

Vista's dead: Microsoft kills an OS and no one cares

Carmi Levy: Wide Angle Zoom Can you kill an operating system? Microsoft is about to find out.

Kantaris Media Player 0.5.7

July 3 - 5:34 PM ET

Wine 1.1.25

July 3 - 5:30 PM ET

ChrisTV Online! Free 4.00

July 3 - 5:22 PM ET

glu 1.0.19 RC1

July 3 - 5:11 PM ET

Website-Watcher 5.1.0 Beta 10

July 3 - 1:20 PM ET