Why would Comcast need 'seat warmers' to appear to show support?

By Jacqueline Emigh | Published February 28, 2008, 3:25 PM

Comcast has admitted to paying "seat warmers" to attend an FCC hearing held Monday, to hear its arguments in favor of blocking P2P file transfers. But Comcast contends that the seat warmers left once company employees showed up.

In a phone interview today, the organizer of a Federal Communications Commission hearing Monday on the grounds of Harvard Law School in Cambridge, Mass., disputed Comcast's statement, telling BetaNews that its paid "seat warmers" were only hired by the Internet service provider to fill seats until Comcast employees turned up to take their places.

Reached on her cell phone today, Catherine Bracy, the hearing organizer, told BetaNews that all of the people who appeared to be seat warmers were still in their spots in the audience at 11:30 am, after the opening statements in the FCC hearing had been completed.

At the hearing, the FCC heard testimony regarding Comcast's apparent blocking of P2P file transfers by its customers.

On Tuesday, Comcast released a written statement responding to published reports that the ISP had paid "seat warmers" to stop people siding against Comcast from gaining entry to the hearing. In it, the company contended that the seat warmers were only hired after the advocacy group Free Press "engaged in a much more extensive campaign to lobby people to attend the hearing."

However, Bracy told BetaNews today that when she arrived at Harvard Law School at 7:15 am on Monday, about 30 to 35 people were already standing outside, waiting to get inside.

"I initially thought, 'This is great! These people are so interested in the topics that they showed up early,'" according to Bracy, who is administrative manager at Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet and Society. "But when I started to give instructions about how to get on the wireless network, nobody seemed to want to get on the wireless network -- and some of them didn't even know what a wireless network is."

"I then started to think that they might not be there because they were interested in the topics," Bracy said.

Bracy noticed that all of the group of early arrivals were still seated at 11:30 am. Meanwhile, others who got to the site of the hearing later had to be turned away, due to lack of space.

Most of the early arrivals were still present at 12:15 pm, in the middle of the first panel discussion, Bracy said. After that, they left the room, one by one, throughout the rest of the day.

But people identifying themselves as Comcast employees did not show up to take the places of the exiting seat warmers, according to the hearing organizer.

Bracy said she recognized some but not all of those who were turned away as employees of Harvard's Berkman Center. "But I did not ask anyone for their affiliations," she told BetaNews.

Photos and descriptions in some publications depict middle-aged men dozing off in the audience along with younger fellows who look like they might be bikers.

Comcast spokespersons were initially unavailable for comment about Bracy's reactions to the company's written statement.

On Tuesday, New York State Attorney General Andrew Cuomo reportedly subpoenaed Comcast's records to look into how the ISP is handling P2P file sharing through programs such as BitTorrent.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

It's really pathetic.

Score: 0

|

"Comcast’s sleeper cell." Classic.

http://www.savetheintern...internet-now-the-public/

Score: 0

|

"Crowd Shaping"

"Denial of Citizen Attack"

This is just too rich.

http://www.cnet.com/8301-13739_1-9879848-46.html

Score: 0

|

Our local Comcast gang is utterly retarded. When do those same FCC beauracrats fine their butts for never using REQUIRED callsigns on their old 35.00 mhz dispatching radios. Federal laws against using obscenities are not limited to just the channels that provide entertainment either.

This corporation ignores FCC regulations whenever it pleases. What kind of IDIOT would place his CABLE radio translator, on frequency surrounded on both sides by the local HIGH powered NPR station? (88.9 NPR, 89.1 Comcast, 89.3 NPR) We get nothing but NOISE on one of Comcast's channels because they're frigging incompetent.

I have never used their damned ISP and am happy with AT&T/Yahoo...

Score: 0

|

I have comcast, we used to have roadrunner in our area, and they were great, then comcast took over and now they throttle all the ftping I try to do. Any file the is over 5-6MB in size goes down from 250k to 44k on upload speeds. I never thought I'd think of switching back to AT&T, but I think I will be doing that shortly. The files I upload are for our redirect for 'maps' for Unreal Tournament 2004. They range in size from 1mb to 40mb in size and its not something done daily, just for new maps or changes to existing ones.

Score: 0

|

I've been on AT&T DSL now for about nine months. Super fast speeds, no limits, and about $24.95 a month.

I've downloaded 3-4 GB in the last couple days.

Score: 0

|

AT&T and Verizon are letting Comcast take the public beating on this one and stuff like this article certainly is not good for Comcast's PR, not that it can get much worse.

Score: 0

|

and dont be surprised if comcast hires more people
to come here and post positive things about the company

Score: 0

|

No, M$ already has this place covered with Astroturf.

Score: 0

|

And PC-Tool. [grins]

Score: 0

|

Ya'll seem to think I blindly defend MSFT...

Do you just skip the topics where I b**** about them, or are you just selectively skipping those posts so that it doesn't interfere with your oh-so-narrow view of the world?

Hate to break it ya, children, but it's not all black or white, love or hate, fanboy or troll. I know it's just easier for you to think in those limited terms.

Wouldn't want anything like reality creeping in on you and messing with your perceptions or anything...

Score: 0

|

Comcast isn't bad until you have to deal with tech support. What a bunch of idiots (until you reach tier 3.)
They recently turned off my internet without any notice and I had to spend more than 2 hours on the phone to get to the department that could turn it back on. What a bunch of ****ers.

If only there was any other provider offering similar speeds in my area...

Score: 0

|

Google Chrome 4: Yes, it's fast, but is it usable?

As Betanews readers have responded to our stories about Chrome's JavaScript superiority...Does that mean we'd actually use this browser? Well...

Video: Netflix on PlayStation 3

Netflix has come to the PlayStation 3 via Blu-ray and BD-Live.

Verizon Wireless launches new Android, Chocolate, and ruggedized phones

The lower-priced Eris joins the Droid, while the Chocolate gets a touchscreen and more music playback.

Early sales figures for Windows 7 nicely high, but do we know why?

Fans of triple-digit surges in figures quoted by Betanews will love this one, as it appears Microsoft rediscovered how to pull off a software launch.

Myka announces its latest Linux-based 'net top box'

Myka's ION brings Boxee, XMBC, and much more to HDTVs.

What hath Mac wrought? A remembrance after a quarter-century

The reason there's a Macintosh today is not because of some brilliant flash of engineering genius, but because Apple had the audacity to learn from its mistakes.

Early build of Moblin 2.1 improves connectivity, but not device support

The Linux Foundation's Atom-centric OS yesterday received a major overhaul with the project release of Moblin 2.1 for netbooks and nettops.

The iPhone's China syndrome: Sales of 5,000 and climbing

There's actually a country where Apple's device is not a godsend, where sales can be measured in the dozens.

New European counterpart to FCC will ensure 'a more neutral net'

Late Thursday night, the ruling telecom administrators of the EU's member nations signed away their final authority to a new entity overseen by the EC.

Sophos study suggests Windows 7 UAC's default setting is self-defeating

Without any anti-virus installed, a Sophos test showed, User Account Control was only capable of thwarting just one malware package out of ten samples chosen.

Indiscreet tweet trips awareness of Web SSL vulnerability

A group of high-level security engineers had been making progress on thwarting a low-level threat to the Web, until somebody blurted it all out on Twitter.