Wikipedia Credibility Under Fire Again

By Ed Oswald | Published December 21, 2005, 3:52 PM

Those looking into the accuracy of Wikipedia following several high-profile cases that showed some may be editing their own entries or intentionally posting false information found even more fodder this week.

An investigation by Rogers Cadenhead of the technology Web log Workbench uncovered that Wikipedia's founder, Jimmy Wales, had changed his own biography 18 times. This included edits to remove references to former Wikipedia employee Larry Sanger as a co-founder of the site. He has also made changes to the entry for Bomis, a search engine he helped create.

The search engine had a pornographic past, which included a section called "Bomis' Babes" with links to adult photos. Wales repeatedly attempted to sweep this portion of the sites history under the table, says Cadenhead.

"Though some Wikipedia editors believe that it's always wrong to edit subjects in which you are involved, this idea is clearly not shared by Wales," Cadenhead wrote.

The changes prompted Larry Sanger to post an angry thread to the Wikipedia Talk forum area on Monday.

"I must say I am amused. Having seen edits like this," referring to his name being removed as founder. "It does seem that Jimmy is attempting to rewrite history. But this is a futile process because in our brave new world of transparent activity and maximum communication, the truth will out."

Wales had publicly frowned the practice of editing your own entries, but he apparently had been engaging in the practice himself. In an interview with Wired News, Wales regrets what he did.

"People shouldn't do it, including me," he told the site. "I wish I hadn't done it. It's in poor taste." He did stress that he only made changes to correct factual errors.

In any case, in January, changes are planned that will attempt to keep unscrupulous vandals from improperly editing Wikipedia entries with false information. This will include a watch on articles that could be at a high-risk for vandalism and the barring of edits from newly registered members. Also, edits would be delayed up to ten minutes.

Still, some of Wikipedia's editors are upset that the open source encyclopedia's credibility issues are now not getting any help from the top.

"If the community can't even get the article on Jimbo right, what does that say about other biographies," a Wikipedia user by the name of David Remahl wrote. "This is damaging to [Wikipedia's] credibility as a whole."

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

What Wales did should have been flagged as a violation of the ethics of autobiographies, end of story.

Wikipedia is going to have to take more of a hand-on approach to the content available on Wikipedia which would best be structured with check-ins only after verification.

Score: 0

|

@zridling

This isn't about profits or money, this is about factual accuracy. Period.

Score: 0

|

18 times?! Oh no! Not 18 TIMES!!!

...get a life.

Score: 0

|

Woah dude!...That must be like an edit every couple months or so?

Score: 0

|

I agree. Only Wikepedia haters think this is a big deal. Any Open Source project receives massive waves of hostility from capitalist pigs who can't find a way to profit from it.

Why is BetaNews reporting this as "news?" It's not.

Score: 0

|

The credibility of an open source project and widly used source of information isn't news? When did that happen?

Score: 0

|

Silly that this is getting so much press. This should stay as an internal arguement at Wikipedia. Things like this help to work out kinks since what Wales did was minor, thought to be in the best interest of Wikipedia, and internal concern was expressed. It helps define how the community feels and proves the balance of power in place from the other editors.

Big deal.

Score: 0

|

It could be worse, you could have millions of dummies growing up thinking that Columbus discovered America?

Score: 0

|

Sure he did. Only *after* the vikings. Well, and then there's the native population...

I myself discovered Wisconsin a few years ago. I'm quite proud of that discovery, actually.

Of course, I believe others had probably discovered it before me...that *would* explain the roads...and those funky water-parks.

Score: 0

|

I discovered a new and unique way that is highly efficient at inserting values into an integer!

Oh wait...damn... AdjustRed()

Why did nobody tell me!?

Score: 0

|

Didn't the Indians discover America?

Score: 0

|

No, that's like saying the Buffalo discovered America. Indians are savages, didn't your fifth grade social studies class teach you anything?

Score: -1

|

i heard the templars discovered america many decades before columbus, and they didn't get lost and confused, they hit off virginia, there's relics

Score: 0

|

You have class.

Score: 0

|

Microsoft's Ray Ozzie: 'Nobody's going to be 100% open'

The mobile apps ecosystems of the world may converge over time, led by apps being ported over across platforms, according to the Chief Software Architect.

Will Firefox beat IE9 to Direct2D rendering?

Just days after Microsoft executives gave conference attendees a peek at a new rendering technology, a Mozilla contributor revealed he's working on the same thing.

Where there's smoke: Apple warranty stance raises troubling questions

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: Smoking can be dangerous not only for your lungs, it appears, but for your Apple hardware warranty.

AOL's decision to rebrand as Aol. takes a bad brand and makes it worse

The idea behind the social Web is to crowd source before bringing out something new. But not at AOL, which new logo debuted with a cry of "fail!" across the blogosphere and Twittersphere today.

Microsoft 'worked with Apple' for Silverlight on iPhone, says Goldfarb

By not making such a big deal out of trying to stream video to the iPhone, Microsoft got a big deal out of it, revealed the Silverlight product manager.

Clicker.com cuts through the Web video chaos

In a world where homemade video and Hollywood movies travel the same pipeline, it's good to have a real search engine to cut through the clutter.

A case study in improving software: What Office 2010 can learn from Notion 3

A music composition product gambles with a complete overhaul, in an effort to make headway against two well-known competitors in a tough market.

Kindle 2 update adds battery life, native PDF reader

Amazon has pushed out an update to the Kindle 2 e-reader that lengthens battery life and adds a native PDF viewer.

Safari on iPhone gets competition from a $1 browser app

Apple likes to say it gives iPhone users a full browsing experience, but a new competitor tries to incorporate more desktop browser features.

Action Replay maker sues Microsoft for Xbox 360 'predatory technological barriers'

Third-party video game accessory maker Datel has filed an antitrust lawsuit against Microsoft over the Xbox 360's recent Dashboard update.

Microsoft's Bob Muglia and Ray Ozzie on Silverlight vs. standards

Bob Muglia: "We're trying to provide people with an environment that has capabilities that you just simply can't do today in the standards-based world."