Circuit City tries a turnaround in a bad economy

By Jacqueline Emigh, BetaNews

April 9, 2008, 7:44 PM

Struggling consumer electronics giant Circuit City pulled a big surprise Wednesday by posting a profitable first quarter, which is amazing considering its sales margins are still sounding alarm bells with investors.

Circuit City's overall sales numbers were down for the fourth quarter of its fiscal year just ended, but it also opened or relocated 22 US superstores and enjoyed gains across Web sales, international sales, and revenues from LCD TVs, video gaming products, GPS, and PC Firedog and home theater services.

"Our weakest areas included projection, tube, and plasma TVs, as the consumer shifts sales focus to large LCDs, which is a trend that we've been seeing across the industry," said Bruce H. Besanko, Circuit City's CFO, in a conference call yesterday.

CEO and Chairman Philip J. Schoonover admitted during the call that, on the whole, Circuit City's fiscal year 2008 -- which ended last February -- was very disappointing.

"The fourth quarter, however, showed some progress, and we expect continued improvement from our turnaround strategies in fiscal year 2009," Schoonover told analysts.

Specifically, the second largest CE retailer in the US earned $4.85 million for the three months ending February 29, compared to $4.25 million for the fourth quarter a year ago. In contrast, Circuit City's much bigger competitor, Best Buy, last week reported earnings of $737 million for its fourth quarter, a 3% drop from the year before.

Circuit City's Schoonover also voiced unhappiness today over profitability margins for the fourth quarter. But he said the chain will work on improving those margins over the year ahead by doing a better job of training sales associates to sell not just higher-margin products but also service after the sale, such as Firedog PC tech support and home theater installation.

"Our under-penetration in PC Firedog services is a tremendous growth engine for Circuit City," Schoonover maintained.

Already, the retailer showed year-over-year sales increases of 11% on those two services alone in the fourth quarter, and 14% in "direct channel" -- or Web-based -- sales.

"Our specific opportunity [with home theater] is not only to help our customers to upgrade to flat and digital but to bring the entire high definition (HD) experience alive in their homes through a digital source, theater-like audio, and post-sales support," according to Schoonover.

Over half of the products ordered over the Web were picked up by customers inside Circuit City stores, which means the Web is bringing them through the door anyway. "We continue to focus on strategies that provide enhanced shopping capabilities for online customers and further integrate all of our shopping channels," the CEO contended.

As a major factor behind the improved profitability for the fourth quarter -- which stretched from December 2007 to February 2008 -- officials pointed to cost reductions in the fourth quarter from "continuing structural changes" such as earlier store closings and a consolidation of Circuit City's previous ten regions into eight regions.

"We exceeded our goal to take $150 million out of SG&A [selling, general, and administrative] expenses this year and actually took out approximately $200 million," Schoonover said. "We [also] achieved greater than expected savings in non-store headcount and indirect spend, which is made up principally from not for resale goods and services."

During the call, Besanko specifically cited 27 store closings over the past year in Circuit City's international segment. Despite those closings, international sales rose 17.4%, reflecting an in-store sales increase of 8.6%in local currency, along with "the favorable impact of foreign exchange rates," Besanko said.

Near the end of the call, the executives also pointed to some market drivers they think will work in Circuit City's favor over the next 12 months.

John J. Kelly, Circuit City's chief marketing officer, mentioned the Olympics in August and the digital-to-analog TV conversion next February as pushing sales of digital TVs and audio systems.

Add a Comment (24 Comments)

BetaNews reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic. Foul language and personal attacks will not be tolerated.

Name (required):

E-mail (required):

Enter Your Comment:

By Hollywood__

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 6:46 PM

Circuit City stores are creepy and depressing from the moment you walk in. Best Buy likes lots of open air, high ceilings, carpet, and the color blue.

CC's red and yellow are very agressive and works great for food chains like McDonalds, Wendy's and Burger King, where blue is calming. People have no clue about the science of color and psychology. I've studied it for years and pour it into my graphic work to set a certain mood based on the overall theme.

If the stored didn't seem like one big dark small coffin when you walk in, people would be more prone to shop there. They built a new Wal Mart by me with skylights everywhere to let in natural light to save energy in the daytime.

The roof is a full teen feet higher than any other WM I've been in. No crappy ceiling tiles or flourescents. They use special blue filter mercury vapor lamps that cast light very close to the sun's natural color. This particular store does triple the sales of the other ones close by simply because it's very open and well designed.

People don't only shop for price, they want an experience too. Did you ever notice that CC is usually lone people shopping and BB has whole families that go there together? You guys probaly think I'm crazy but I have read countless studies on this.

One of them involved an office that moved from a windowless brick building with low ceilings, bad lighting, etc.., they moved across the street into a high glass atrium style building with plants, soothing ambient music and a waterfall. Low and behold, people started showing up for work more often, and productivity went through the roof. No raises, just a new building that people felt very comfortable in.

Most of this happens on a subconscious level, which Vegas finally figured out about 15 years ago. Check out a study of the relationship of the most played slots vs the hight of the ceiling above them, it's absolutely fascinating.

Score: 0

By Scary Guy

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 3:02 PM

Circuit City sucks, or at least the one by me. Last time I was their none of their staff knew anything and half the registers were glitching out. I don't really have anything against them, I just wish they'd get their act together.

Score: 0

By speedmeister

edited Apr 11, 2008 - 3:17 AM

I personally wouldn't miss Circuit City. I can't think of any thing I have ever purchased there nor can I think of anything that they sell that isn't better served by other stores.

I could say many of the same things about Best Buy but they seem to be weathering the recent downturn a lot better than Circuit City. I am not a big fan of Best Buy but BB must be doing something better than Circuit City. What it is I don't know.

Score: 0

By siryak

edited Apr 10, 2008 - 3:38 PM

You can't really bash the whole chain based on 1 store. It's like ditching Taco Bell everywhere because you got a bad burrito at one somewhere along the way. Just because one had a bad egg doesn't mean they all do. Personally the CC near me has the best and most knowledgeable reps in town.

I see this all the time though. You see someone saying they are never gonna by from XX company because a rep in one of their stores treated them badly. The same point above applies.

Score: 0

By Scary Guy

posted Apr 11, 2008 - 4:10 AM

I see your point, but I'm just dissing the one, which used to be decent. However because of that one I won't shop at any others since the next closest one is a bit out of the way (the difference between 1 mile and 9 miles). As was stated in an above reply I can get what I want elsewhere that's also closer.

Score: 0

By GS5

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 4:43 PM

"It's like ditching Taco Bell everywhere because you got a bad burrito at one somewhere along the way."

Are you suggesting that Taco Bell actually has good Burritos???

Score: 0

By siryak

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 9:08 PM

Lol no...I don't eat the burritos. Chalupas or Gorditas all the way. :)

Score: 0

By akconsult

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 12:15 PM

You have to wonder whether much of Circuit's 1st Qtr. profits are due more to its layoffs and the closure of CompUSA. It would be understandable tht the CompUSA customers would reluctantly start wandering into Circuit City - as long as they didn't need a lot of assistance

Score: 0

By JonIn92656

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 11:15 AM

What good does it do to post any profit when it is at the expenses of their most valuable assets - their employees? Since Circuit City decide to fire any employee making more than $10.00 per hour, and then rehire them weeks later for much less money, I refuse to purchase anything from them. Their actions were deplorable! Frankly, I hope they go under. I urge everyone to boycott Circuit City.

Score: 0

By Hollywood__

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 6:51 PM

I'd gladly go to BB and pay $100 more for a TV than buy it at CC, who has no Reward Zone type program that I know of.

These BB people constantly send me vouchers in the mail. I got my Garmin portable nav for free. Plus I can beat the crap out of them on price, I often pay $50 over cost for big ticket items, thats when I pull out the coupons and the vouchers and rape them even more.

Score: 0

By Niro

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 11:51 AM

Well we're in a struggling economy, this is what companies do. This is the nature of the beast, if someone is willing to do your job for less money to a standard the company is comfortable with, you're in trouble, that's just how it is in any field. I'm sorry for the people that were laid off, but you're going to boycott a company for wanting to make a profit? What should they have done...kept the more expensive employees and said "hey, we're losing tons of money, but we love our employees!"? Yea that would have gone over real well with stock holders.

Score: 0

By speedmeister

posted Apr 11, 2008 - 3:08 AM

I don't think that they should kept their current staffing in light of slower sales but there were definitely better ways of handling layoffs then the way they did it. Besides the bad publicity that was created by the manner of layoffs it certainly hurt employee morale. When you lay off the most experienced sales people you send a message to all the other employees that your loyalty to the company doesn't pay off. Anybody who was thinking of trying to work there way into management at CC no doubt went elsewhere.

Score: 0

By siryak

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 3:33 PM

Very well said.

Score: 0

By Hellcat_M

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 3:19 PM

This is true, it sucks but true. Employees aren't going to go up to a store manager and say "I know things are bad, I'll take less money" and if they didn't cut costs they'd go out of business. That what happens when you work for someone else and their is a depression coming. I go to BB for some things and CC for some things. CC installed my car stereo for free when BB wanted to charge. I do wish CompUSA would have stuck around instead of CC, but oh well.

Score: 0

By siryak

edited Apr 10, 2008 - 10:24 PM

I don't know about instead of(maybe but that would be a hard choice), but I do agree that CompUSA was a great place to shop.

Edit: One thing that I have noticed is their newsletter looks exactly like Tigerdirect's. So did I miss the part where CompUSA became a Tigerdirect reseller or something? Even their site looks exactly the same except it is CompUSA branded instead of Tigerdirect.

Score: 0

By speedmeister

posted Apr 11, 2008 - 3:10 AM

Probably because Tiger Direct's parent company, Systemax, bought out the CompUSA earlier this year.

Score: 0

By dvferret

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 11:34 AM

That is stupid to say. If they went under, Bestbuy would be the only major CE retailer left, thus meaning no competition for lower prices.

Score: 0

By Hollywood__

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 6:53 PM

Ever heard of Wal Mart, Sam's club, Sears, JC Penny's, Fry's? Hopefully Fry will take over a bunch of the closed CC stores.

Score: 0

By God Dammit

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 2:32 PM

There's Fry's Electronics.

Score: 0

By siryak

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 3:31 PM

Fry's is not anywhere near as widespread as CC and BB.

Score: 0

By dvferret

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 3:56 PM

Yah, this is the first time ive even heard of them.

Score: 0

By siryak

posted Apr 10, 2008 - 9:11 PM

It is one of the biggest electronic stores I have ever been in. Everything that you could imagine that requires electricity is in that store almost! If I had to choose an electronics store to be close by I would pick Fry's without giving it a second thought.

Score: 0

By DGMayor

edited Apr 10, 2008 - 3:17 PM

Not in the east.. There's three east of the Mississippi. Two in Georgia, one in Indiana.

Score: 0