German ruling may clear victims of legal liability for Wi-Fi theft

By Ed Oswald | Published July 10, 2008, 5:51 PM

A court in the country has ruled that Internet users who are victims of Wi-Fi theft cannot be held responsible for illegal P2P activity if it occurs as a result of that incident.

The development could lend support to efforts elsewhere to clear victims of any liability when it comes to copyright infringement. The argument that router owners are indeed liable, has been used by Davenport Lyons in its work with the industry in the UK.

With the blessing of the recording industry, the firm has been sending out letters to those who may have not secured their wireless networks. Unbeknownst to them, someone used their connection to download pirated content over a P2P network.

Davenport had been using an earlier German court ruling that seemed to suggest connection owners were liable for any illicit activity over their connection, and expected the courts in the UK to rule in the same fashion.

Letters have been going out to those suspected since at least the beginning of this year. However, supporters of P2P point out that subsequent decisions have been made in the contrary, siding with the individual over the industry.

This week's ruling seems to continue to follow the same premise, and overturns the exact judgment that Davenport was using to justify its own letters. It was not clear whether the firm would reword its letters to reflect the new court decision.

A request for comment from BetaNews likely reached the London firm after the close of business Thursday local time, although Davenport may answer Friday.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

This just proves that the RIAA is just spinning their wheels. The idea of "pirating" so way too broad to cover and it is VERY difficult, and in some cases impossible, to pinpoint direct sources of the offender(s).
There are way too many minor instances that prove the RIAA is really getting nowhere.
Wifi "theft" is so widespread that you cannot punish the unknowing "host".
Someday, hopefully, the RIAA will dissolve or soon realize that they are getting nowhere.

Score: 0

|

RIAA believes pirating is not paying 5 times for the same thing..

Score: 0

|

Good. Now the U.S. needs to implement this ruling.

I agree with kazzi, common sense at last.

Score: 0

|

Common sense at last.

Score: 0

|

They send out letters to people just because they want to share their internet or dif not lock down their personal router?? This does not make sense.. an IP is an address not a MAC address. The RIAA/MPAA once again is above the law or trying to be!
It ruling shows that the courts are getting educated about that the internet is..

I can see the ISP cutting service for this but getting sued??

Score: 0

|

*ponders*

You are aware that this is a ruling in Germany, and the organizations you listed are:
Recording Industry Association of America
Motion Picture Association of America

Notice a problem here?

Score: 0

|

'A pivot from war to peace:' The AMD + Intel armistice, in their own words

An extraordinary day in technology history is recognized by two long-time rivals that mutually decided it's futile to fight anyplace else except the marketplace.

PS3, Xbox to soon get Twitter, Facebook integration

Both Microsoft's Xbox 360 and Sony's PlayStation 3 will integrate with Facebook in the near future.

Windows Marketplace for Mobile now available in browser, iTunes' App Store still not

You can now check out what Windows Marketplace for Mobile has to offer without a Windows Phone.

Microsoft damage control after marketer claims Win7 inspired by Mac

Have you ever said anything you wish you could take back? Ever? No? Not even once? Well then, you won't sympathize with a mid-level Microsoft manager today.

Blockbuster's way down, but poised for a comeback

Though it took a serious beating in 2009, Blockbuster CEO Jim Keyes says the company can turn it around.

iTunes Preview deson't go far enough to create Web-based option for store

Apple has rolled out iTunes Preview, a Web interface for browsing iTunes.

PDC 2009 Preview: The move to Office 2010 and Visual Studio 2010

The major focus of Microsoft's conference next week will likely be explaining why two pillars of its software sales strategy deserve to remain where they are.

Dell's first smartphone aids the Android onslaught

Longtime PC leader Dell has finally announced its Android-based smarphone.

After the Intel + AMD armistice: Do we really want a level playing field?

Scott Fulton On Point: One by one, the reasons for us to continue suspending the course toward open and fair competition in IT, are dropping like flies.

FLO TV launches pocketable, smartphone-like TVs

Qualcomm's FLO TV Personal Television made by HTC launches in retail today.

Google acquires Gizmo5, builds IP telephony portfolio

Google Voice today confirmed rumors that it would acquire IP telephony company Gizmo5