Glitch reports mount for e-voting machines

By Angela Gunn | Published October 30, 2008, 12:15 AM

It's six days until the American elections. Do you know whether your electronic voting machines are behaving?

The overwhelming majority of voters on Tuesday will encounter machines from Premier Election Systems, Hart InterCivic, Sequoia Voting Systems, or Election Systems and Software (ES&S). For your consideration, we present a roundup of problems currently known to be manifesting or to have recently manifested in testing and early voting, sorted by vendor.

  • ES&S - The Omaha-based ES&S is, globally, the largest provider of election gear.

    Problems with vote-flipping on the ES&S iVotronic Touch Screen Voting System have been reported four states already in 2008: West Virginia, Tennessee, Texas, and Missouri. In many cases, it's suspected that the machines are poorly calibrated. The problem seems to crop up most frequently with straight-party tickets (that is, where one votes all-Democratic or all-Republican).

    The Brennan Center for Justice at New York University, concerned that the problems seem to be rather widespread, sent a letter to the secretaries of state in the 16 states where iVotronics are in use, strongly suggesting that the states follow West Virginia's lead and recalibrate their machines during early voting and before Tuesday's main event.

    Another iVotronics problem turned up in South Carolina, where voters discovered that choosing candidates in races where one is supposed to make multiple choices resulted in weirdness on the final-review screen, which the machine presents to voters as a last step before recording their picks. When multiple candidates are picked, the final screen notes only that there are multiple picks -- it doesn't say who. A pre-election fix for the flaw isn't possible at this point.

    ES&S was previously known as American Information Systems and was run by retiring Nebraska senator Chuck Hagel. Along with Diebold, the company faced a number of lawsuits in the wake of problems during the 2004 election.

  • Hart InterCivic - The accessibility-friendly eSlate has, as previously reported here, flipped votes in some elections in Texas this year.
  • Premier / Diebold - In August, Premier Election Solutions -- better known by its former name, Diebold -- has warned at least 1,750 voting jurisdictions around the country that their machines are in danger of dropping ballot totals for entire precincts.

    The problem rests with the tabulation software. According to the company, a logic error can cause votes queued to for counting to be dropped if more votes come into the queue -- a particular problem for larger precincts that might be using multiple memory cards during counts. The problem affects all 19 of the company's machine models, both touchscreen (DRE) and optical-scanning units.

    The problem was not a fresh revelation; it was originally revealed when various Ohio precincts spotted bad vote counts. The company first blamed anti-virus software and "human error," but further testing by Ohio elections officials and in-house high-volume testing at Premier confirmed that the problem lay in the software.

    According to Premier, the bug has been in force for about a decade.

  • Sequoia - Testing results on Sequoia machines are at the center of conflict in New Jersey over the results of independent evaluation of the company's AVC Advantage touch-screen units. BetaNews reported previously on a judicial holdup in releasing the report. The report has since been released to the public.

    Researchers concluded that the AVC Advantage can be hacked in just seven minutes by swapping out either of two chips; the hack could also be propagated as a firmware change on audio-ballot cartridges, and a would-be hacker needs neither advanced training not full access to the source code to do the job.

    Sequoia disputed the findings, claiming unreasonable testing conditions and inappropriate machine configuration.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

I do believe and strongly hope that those responsible for voting machine cheating should and will be treated as the criminals they are, be prosecuted for treason under the laws of the USA, and end up in jail.

Score: 0

|

And sadly, Windows 7 threads all have at least 20 comments, whereas this has... 1. Well, 2 now. ;-)

It's a bit insane how quickly we have moved to E-voting, despite the widespread reports of problems. I'm surprised they've let these clearly incompetent companies run the show, too. There is such a thing as government run software/hardware development, and it can be a lot better than you might imagine. What am I talking about here? Why NASA, of course. Surely the accuracy of our voting process is as important as sending people into space, right? So why can't we just put the NASA software team onto the problem? They'd have it sussed in no time. Then open source the results, and viola! http://www.fastcompany.c...zine/06/writestuff.html

Score: 0

|

This is why I am not a huge fan of E voting, because its the biggest accomplishment for a hacker. In my opinion the only way E voting will work is if there is a security guard at every one. Bur the problem then is that people will no longer be able to vote privately.

www.talkprice.net

Score: 0

|

PDC 2009 Day 0: Vista is through

If there was any doubt in your mind that Microsoft is putting Vista behind it, the first session at PDC would eliminate it for good.

Samsung releases another Android: where will it fit in with Bada approaching?

Samsung today announced the Galaxy Spica, sequel to its first Android handset destined for Europe and Asia.

Apple was NOT more profitable selling cell phones than Nokia in Q3

Recent reports that Apple's phone business generated $1.6 billion profit compared to $1.1 billion for Nokia don't add up. The companies' financial disclosures tell all.

PDC 2009 Preview: The move to Office 2010 and Visual Studio 2010

The major focus of Microsoft's conference next week will likely be explaining why two pillars of its software sales strategy deserve to remain where they are.

Twitter to abandon 'politically biased' suggested user list

Twitter's suggested list of users to follow will be going away, says co-founder Biz Stone.

Windows Marketplace for Mobile launches on WinMo 6.0 and 6.1

No longer isolated to Windows Mobile 6.5, the Windows Phone app store has opened up to older versions of Windows Mobile.

The Internet can still be a positive force, World Wide Web Foundation says

Sir Tim Berners-Lee's World Wide Web Foundation has launched worldwide operations.

Blockbuster's way down, but poised for a comeback

Though it took a serious beating in 2009, Blockbuster CEO Jim Keyes says the company can turn it around.

iTunes Preview doesn't go far enough to create Web-based option for store

Apple has rolled out iTunes Preview, a Web interface for browsing iTunes.

Dell's first smartphone aids the Android onslaught

Longtime PC leader Dell has finally announced its Android-based smarphone.

After the Intel + AMD armistice: Do we really want a level playing field?

Scott Fulton On Point: One by one, the reasons for us to continue suspending the course toward open and fair competition in IT, are dropping like flies.