Google India could be ordered to break one blogger's anonymity

By Tim Conneally | Published August 15, 2008, 4:21 PM

A construction equipment company in Mumbai, India, has asked that country's high court to order Google India to disclose the identity of "Toxic Writer," a blogger who made defamatory remarks about its mining project in Mozambique.

According to the original complaint filed by Gremach Infrastructure Equipments and Projects Ltd., the ninth paragraph of a blog entry entitled "toxic fumes" contained defamatory material that amounted to a smear campaign against it. However, because the blog post was taken down on an interim order from the Bombay High Court, the actual text is unavailable and even some cached copies cannot be retrieved.

Still, some cached replies contain information as to the subject matter within the contentious blog.

An unnamed source from Gremach has been quoted as suspecting "corporate rivalry behind the hate campaign." Indeed, the blog post began: "Here's what somebody from the steel sector has sent me: As an employee of an Indian steel maker using the blast furnace route, we too are keenly watching the developments in Mozambique in order to secure our..."

The post reportedly goes on to describe an investor whose investments were tied up in Germach's rapidly falling stock, as the manufacturer allegedly diverted funds to a company called Austral Coke. Germach's stock price has dropped in value from Rs 500 ($11.90) to Rs 86 ($2.00) per share as of closing bell yesterday.

A reply entitled, "Gremach Investor Don't Fear" posted by a user named Chinu on February 11, 2008, reads in its entirety:

I am Employee of Gremach Infrastructure. I bought the shares at Rs. 440. But i don't have any Fear because technically stock is very Strong. Mr Toxic Writer we have already launched Police FIR against your mail , Your Computer and your ID is access by Cyber Crime Department. Now your time is finished now it's a game of 5 days.

This reply corroborates reports that Gremach had first contacted Mumbai Police to find the blogger's identity before taking legal action. Google was given four weeks to disclose the name of the blogger in the order issued by Justice Dhananjay Chandrachud, but has yet to do so. The case will be heard again within the next two weeks.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Google will cave in and provide the info they want. Why? They've done it on the past, and that doesn't even cover the censorship that Google gave their blessing to when some of the iffy dictatorships flexed their muscle.

Score: 0

|

"Do no Evil"

It's funny how once google became a public corp that motto isn't even enforceable by them anymore. They are at the whim of their shareholders and law enforcement bureaus now.

Score: 0

|

Funny how some crimes can't be ejudicated across international lines but some can. Murderers can escape back to their home country and take years (if ever) to be extradited, but a blog post can force an entire corporation to spill their guts and forfeit privacy? Wow. I hope Google doesn't give in.

Score: 0

|

Google rolls out real-time search, Near Me Now, extended personalization

Over time, searches from PCs and mobile phones will grow even "more personalized." But what about user privacy and search results that give you "the truth"?

Intel's marriage of CPU and GPU not ready for prime time

Although there will be an Intel component this month that can compute and plot in parallel, Betanews was told today, it won't be based on Project "Larrabee."

An alternative to Research in Motion's enterprise e-mail? There's an app for that

Good Technology today released an iPhone app compatible with its enterprise e-mail solution.

Playing catch-up in 2010: Windows Mobile, BlackBerry, and Symbian

Microsoft, RIM, and Nokia are each working on improved mobile operating systems. But could these efforts add up to too little, too late?

Windows fix for TLS security bug still forthcoming, won't be Tuesday

Anyone looking for a fix for last month's discovery of a potentially serious security hole in TLS and SSL may have to wait until everyone is ready to act together.

Not the first, not the last, technology predictions for 2010

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: The real truth is probably that what went around in 2009, will come around to haunt us next year.

Google Goggles: Hands on with the Shazam of the Real World

Google today unveiled Goggles, its visual search lab for Android devices that identifies objects by sight.

Microsoft: Windows 7 Family Pack wasn't 'pulled,' it just sold out

If you hurry, you may still be able to find the last Family Pack upgrade editions hanging around retail store shelves, but probably not so much online.

Clever iPhone game returns after being bumped over a name dispute

The game's simple concept and multitude of platforms and puzzles manage to pull off a retro, 8-bit style that's reminiscent of an old Atari game given a modern makeover.

Report: Microsoft to randomize Europe's browser screen choices

The fact that "A" is for "Apple" was apparently at the heart of browser vendor objections to Microsoft's alternative to listing IE first.

Will Nokia's plans further alienate American consumers?

A look at Nokia's plans for the coming years does little to shine up the company's increasingly dull image.