Microsoft Widens Download Checkpoint

By Nate Mook, BetaNews

October 28, 2004, 4:04 PM

After participation that has "exceeded expectations," Microsoft is expanding its Windows Genuine Advantage pilot, which requires users to validate their Windows license in exchange for special perks at the Microsoft Download Center. Changes to the program include added languages and exclusive access to software.

"To help differentiate the value of genuine Windows from counterfeit versions, Microsoft will now make a variety of special software offerings available exclusively to customers who validate as genuine," a Microsoft spokesperson explained to BetaNews.

These software titles include Photo Story 3 for Windows, which was previously sold as part of the Microsoft Plus Digital Media Edition add-on, and an upcoming Holiday Fun Pack. Validated users will also receive 50-percent discounts on five MSN Zone games and Microsoft's Hosted SharePoint Service. A OneNote trial will soon be offered as well.

While the company set an initial goal of 20,000 customers, an overwhelming 820,000 have opted-in since the pilot's launch last month with few customer service inquiries.

Microsoft would not say whether the positive response makes it more likely for the company to fight piracy by prohibiting non-genuine Windows users from downloading, but acknowledges the pilot is part of "Microsoft's effort...to enforce anti-piracy policies and laws."

"Make no mistake that the program is as much about fighting piracy as rewarding customers," Jupiter Research senior analyst Joe Wilcox told BetaNews. "As part of its fiscal 2005 first quarter announcement last week, Microsoft revealed that sales of Windows licenses to PC makers grew six percent year over year compared to estimated 10 percent worldwide PC growth. One reason for the disparity: Growth in geographies with high piracy rates."

The validation process is strikingly similar to Windows Product Activation: A PC's hardware profile is matched up with the customer's 25-character Product Key. During the pilot, users who are found to be running non-genuine copies of Windows will be given information on how to obtain a legitimate copy of Windows before being allowed to download their requested file.

Education plays a pivotal role in discouraging piracy and Microsoft says that many customers "want to know whether or not their reseller sold them a genuine version of Windows." But Jupiter's Wilcox questions whether Windows Genuine Advantage takes the best approach.

"Validation could penalize consumers that may have unknowingly purchased pirated copies of Windows on new PCs," said Wilcox. "Should they be punished because the seller broke the law? I'm not convinced the burden should be placed on the buyer, if it's the seller that stole from Microsoft."

At the moment, however, Microsoft says it is only testing the waters and gathering feedback from Windows Genuine Advantage. "It is too early to speculate what might result from the expanded pilot," a Microsoft spokesperson told BetaNews.

Add a Comment (11 Comments)

BetaNews reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic. Foul language and personal attacks will not be tolerated.

Name (required):

E-mail (required):

Enter Your Comment:

By IVStalin

posted Nov 1, 2004 - 1:43 PM

It was Windows Product Activation that originally convinced me to switch to Linux. Now I am glad that I did. This kind of snooping on users is unacceptable. Offering bribes to allow Microsoft to check if your copy is legal is doing nothing more than preparing legal users for acceptance of such tactics in the future, and is as morally bankrupt as 'pirating' your copy of Windows. Illegal users are hardly likely to submit to this check - even if Microsoft can't legally gather additional details about them. I still have Windows as a dual boot OS, but after the recent security nightmare, I think it should be the other way round - users having access to Microsofts QA plans and source to check the quality of what they have paid a significant amount of money for.

Score: 0

By bigmac

posted Nov 2, 2004 - 1:08 PM

Unacceptable? I really wouldn't say that; Microsoft owns the software, so if they want to limit who they release it to that's their business. What's more unacceptable is the pirating of software that's done. That's unacceptable too, right? Since you can't change people to not break the law, you have to make other measurements. Yes, it makes things less convenient for those who aren't breaking the law, but that's no different than anywhere else.

Score: 0

By mjm01010101

posted Oct 30, 2004 - 3:10 PM

I've heard cracked Volume License keys work fine--- begging the question--- what is the point? Even Microsoft can't tell what is a legit or not key.

Score: 0

By rijp

posted Nov 1, 2004 - 4:25 PM

Like duh, that's what this is designed to prevent. A cracked Key only works to install it.. locally. Not to authenticate it over the internet. When you try it, the server will reject it.. unless you have a developers or open license copy.

Score: 0

By bourgeoisdude

posted Nov 1, 2004 - 1:01 PM

You are absolutely right.

Score: 0

By x-ray

posted Oct 29, 2004 - 9:09 AM

Get ' Rollercoaster 3 ' then you get thsi program too

Score: 0

By Eden7c

edited Oct 29, 2004 - 8:31 AM

I went through it yesterday and never could find Photo Story 3!?

I did find Photo Story 2 LE but the most usefull tools in it are lacked out.

EDIT....

Woups .... Oh well it worked this morning dunno what I did different...Oh yeah instead of using the Active X gizmo I used the Hypertext one.

Score: 0

By kgruber

posted Oct 28, 2004 - 5:33 PM

I participated in the pilot program, and believe it strikes the appropriate balance of protecting individual privacy and a software company's right to protect their intellectual property.

This scheme will only AUTHENTICATE valid keys, and will REJECT unofficial generated VLK for example.

Score: 0

By skonrad

posted Oct 28, 2004 - 7:10 PM

Well, it actually rejects my key right now, although it is perfectly legal. But I also do think that Microsoft has every right in the world to do that.

Score: 0