Pakistan YouTube incident adds to international outage

By Tim Conneally | Published February 25, 2008, 2:27 PM

After a two hour stretch yesterday of refusing service to YouTube users across the globe, the Google-owned site said Pakistan is to blame.

The Pakistan Telecommunication Authority ordered ISPs to re-route traffic away from a specific YouTube URL pointing to a trailer for Dutch Politician Geert Wilders' anti-Islamic video.

Wilders' video was widely anticipated to incite unrest among the Muslim community abroad, as the far right-wing politician is an outspoken anti-Islamist. Wilders told the BBC his film shows that the Koran is an inspiration for murder. Iran has already put pressure on the Netherlands to ban the film's release.

In YouTube's official statement regarding the two-hour outage, Pakistan was determined to be the source of "erroneous Internet Protocols" to which traffic was being routed. Though in the statement, YouTube does not detail exactly what happened, analysts say Pakistan's faulty route map somehow leaked and was adopted by PCCW, a major Asian telco. PCCW then broadcast the new route, and routers throughout much of the world changed their route maps accordingly, sending everyone in the wrong direction.

Preventative content blocking is not uncommon on the video site, as a result of other nations that have deemed videos harmful. China found some to be subversive, Iran found some immoral, Turkey found one in particular to have illegally insulted the name and image of its founding father Ataturk, Morocco determined some to be too critical of its treatment of Western Saharan peoples, Brazil found some to be embarrassing to public figures, and Thailand found one to be too critical of King Bhumbiol Adulyadej.

However, due to the inflammatory nature of Wilders' video and the offense to Muslims worldwide, some are questioning whether this was actually a simple mistake in blocking, or a premeditated move by Islamic extremists.

Pakistan has felt the effects of unfavorable media coverage since the Kargil Conflict in the late 1990s, a battle with the Indian military in Jammu and Kashmir. Due to the growing power of the Internet and media there at that time, some analysts believe the larger and more credible Indian media helped the country garner worldwide support, and defame Pakistan. Former prime minister -- and recent assassination victim -- Benazir Bhutto spoke in 1999, calling Kargil "Pakistan's Biggest Blunder."

Shortly after this, Pervez Musharraf took over as the country's leader. Early in his tenure, Musharraf spoke out against extremism and terrorism, pledged to battle islamic extremism within Pakistan, and took measures to change the country's unstable political hierarchy.

Of these, the elections in 2007 were viewed as a move by the country toward Democracy. "Islam and democracy are fully incompatible," Geert Wilders told The Washington Post in 2005. "They will never be compatible -- not today, and not in a million years."

A month after Musharraf's election, he declared a state of emergency due to Islamist militants and interference from the judiciary. He ordered the arrest of political dissidents, activists, lawyers and supreme court justices, and shut down all private television stations.

After resigning from his military position to act as a civilian leader, Musharraf's PML-Q party lost control of Parliament, one senior opposition leader called for the president to step down.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

...analysts say Pakistan's faulty route map somehow leaked and was adopted by PCCW, a major Asian telco. ..."
Why does a major Asian telco get its route map from Pakistan ?! Scratch, scratch.

Score: 0

|

Go take a hike Tim.
When politics is not your area dont &^%*ing try your hands on it. What they &*$k you think since you are from west you know every damn detail about the demographics of the world and specially the asia. You do not even know about your own roots sweety...... Musharraf has never been prime minister... correct check history u f*&^ing ba$^^ed.

What do you have to say on the comsat's T&C that my friend has post here.... i know you do not have the guts to come here and respond to any of this...............FU

Score: 0

|

Hey!!
Who has written this above story ..... Musharraf is not a "priminister" but he is a president and also the elections were not held in 2007 but they are held recently in februry 2008... so much mistakes!!!!!

Score: 0

|

What, again?

Score: 0

|

Lol @ funny American using word "foreign". You can try to go on american TV and try to say "We have freedom of ****ing speech". You will get censored.

Score: 0

|

Oh, I just got ****ing censored! lol! Freedom of speech! Damn you christian hippocrites!

Score: 0

|

What? No HDDVD vs BlueRay talk? No one here knows anything about the world, or has no response?

This is common place with foreign countries to jack with the internet... they don't have free speech/expression everywhere... so, they get what they get!

I wonder what there "Terms and Conditions" document states on their internet connections...

Score: 0

|

Wonder no more! I actually found it!

This is what the Pakistani Internet Service Provider "Terms and Conditions" document states:
(The Internet Provider) "reserves the right to refuse to transmit or post, and to remove or block, any information or materials, in whole or in part, that it, in its sole discretion, deems to be in violation of the "Content and information restrictions" section above in this Policy, harmful to its network or customers using the Service, negatively affecting its network or customers using the Service, or otherwise inappropriate, regardless of whether this material or its dissemination is unlawful."

Clear enough, right?

...

Oh! Wait! No, I messed up. That was actually COMCAST'S "Terms and Conditions" document, not the Pakistani one. But I'll keep looking for it. Meanwhile, you can take a look at the rest of the Comcast document here:
http://www6.comcast.net/terms/use/

Enjoy! :)

Score: 0

|

I was thinking: "Hey, that sounds just like ATT's."

Score: 0

|

This is great!!
Its always good to start from comments
Guys who have post there comments are far more interesting then the one who have posted.
Great work all you.

Score: 0

|

Security firm: Windows patches not responsible for 'Black Screen of Death'

On second thought, maybe that access control list thingie with the lockdown something-or-rather didn't trigger an alleged, perhaps non-existent, pandemic.

Windows desktops and notebooks reach near price-performance parity for Holiday 2009

Gone are the days when average Windows desktop offered more for less than laptops.

Latest Firefox 3.6 beta fixes 133 bugs, promises faster page load times

A once-sluggish beta testing process has kicked into overdrive, with astonishing success at finding serious bugs. Will Mozilla be able to fix all the others in time?

Confirmed: Office 2010 to ship in June

Two weeks after Microsoft had been expected to draw a clearer roadmap for its principal applications suite, it's finally ready to commit to the end of H1.

Apple settles with Psystar except for 'circumvention devices'

The fracas with the Florida clone computer maker might have ended today had Apple not have muddled the issue over a cheap piece of Psystar software.

Microsoft denies latest 'Black Screen of Death' claims

After an anti-malware producer announced a fix to what it says is a swarm of recent KSoD problems, evidence of the swarm itself has yet to turn up.

New EU antitrust commissioner will oversee Microsoft, Oracle+Sun, Intel issues

As one of Europe's most prominent politicians shifts positions in January, her replacement remains a question mark over technology's biggest issues.

Without its own 'iTablet' yet, is Apple missing the boat?

Steve Jobs is on record as dissing "single-purpose" devices like e-readers. But given their recent popularity, was that a mistake?

Not-so-mobile battery life: Time to force the issue

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: If power efficiency is important when you buy a car or even a motorcycle, why shouldn't it matter for a smartphone?

Apple invokes DMCA, claims Psystar is 'trafficking in circumvention devices'

In trying to close the book on possibly the last attempt at a Mac clone, Apple cites from its own landmark case...but may actually be misinterpreting it.

The fallacy of Facebook privacy

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: If an insurance company learns something interesting about its client through the Internet, is that snooping?