Qualcomm Sues Nokia in Patent Dispute

By Ed Oswald | Published November 7, 2005, 11:32 AM

Qualcomm announced on Monday that it had filed a lawsuit against competitor Nokia, accusing the company of infringement on 12 patents related to the manufacture of devices that adhere to the GSM standard. The suit seeks a halt to Nokia's phone sales in the United States, as well as monetary damages.

Nokia along with five other manufacturers had complained last week to the European Commission over Qualcomm's business practices. The companies alleged that Qualcomm was attempting to shut out competitors in making chips for 3G mobile phones.

In the suit, Qualcomm says that in order for GSM to remain competitive against CDMA in the 3G arena, companies like Nokia have used patented technologies to speed up data rates and enhance capacity of their networks. Qualcomm had filed a similar lawsuit against Broadcom, which included six of the patents referenced in the Nokia complaint, back in July.

"Until recently, we had been led to believe that these issues might be resolved cooperatively and amicably," Qualcomm general counsel Louis Lupin said in a statement. "However, it now appears that a cooperative resolution of these issues is quite unlikely and we must move forward with the litigation in order to protect our rights and to get these issues resolved."

Nokia had no immediate comment on the suit.

Whether the companies like it or not, they all must work together to push the 3G W-CDMA standard. Qualcomm has contributed significantly to the standard, but competitors such as Nokia and Ericsson also say they have made contributions and expect royalties.

However, Qualcomm has stuck to its licensing terms, which have led to the disagreements.

"Qualcomm is prepared to offer licenses under its essential GSM/GPRS/EDGE patents on fair and reasonable terms free from unfair discrimination to any company that requests one," the company said.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

I'm so sick of patent disputes I could spit...I'm not saying this one is legit or not, only that I'm sick of stupid lawsuits...

EDIT: I've looked over more of the details on this case, and found some disturbing facts. What's worse than frivolous lawsuits? Legitimate lawsuits filed because a company thinks they can get away with something as the lawsuit would hurt consumers too. Be as it may, the law is the law. Haven't done enough research to know but based on other news sites' story, it looks like the folks at Nokia are actually being the jerks in this case...maybe now they might settle. I hope they do for consumers' sake.

Score: 0

|

The phrase "Only in America" comes to mind.

Score: 0

|

Intel's marriage of CPU and GPU not ready for prime time

Although there will be an Intel component this month that can compute and plot in parallel, Betanews was told today, it won't be based on Project "Larrabee."

Playing catch-up in 2010: Windows Mobile, BlackBerry, and Symbian

Microsoft, RIM, and Nokia are each working on improved mobile operating systems. But could these efforts add up to too little, too late?

Advertising is the wrong model for the open Web

Cloud services and technologies released since 2006 make anyone a publisher or broadcaster. There is simply too much ad space for the amount of available advertising.

Acer eclipses Dell for #2 spot in global PC shipments, says iSuppli data

It literally does look like a 360-degree turnaround in Dell's fortunes, as the bells of bad tidings now toll solely for Dell.

Microsoft: Windows 7 Family Pack wasn't 'pulled,' it just sold out

If you hurry, you may still be able to find the last Family Pack upgrade editions hanging around retail store shelves, but probably not so much online.

Clever iPhone game returns after being bumped over a name dispute

The game's simple concept and multitude of platforms and puzzles manage to pull off a retro, 8-bit style that's reminiscent of an old Atari game given a modern makeover.

An alternative to Research in Motion's enterprise e-mail? There's an app for that

Good Technology today released an iPhone app compatible with its enterprise e-mail solution.

Report: Microsoft to randomize Europe's browser screen choices

The fact that "A" is for "Apple" was apparently at the heart of browser vendor objections to Microsoft's alternative to listing IE first.

Will Nokia's plans further alienate American consumers?

A look at Nokia's plans for the coming years does little to shine up the company's increasingly dull image.

Bing bonked by service outage Thursday, Microsoft configured the wrong server

It's always nice to have a backup, but it's even nicer to remember which one is the backup. That's the lesson Bing's admins learned yesterday evening.

Survey reveals there are more women than men, including on social networks

If you think you can market your products and services online as though you're selling car batteries in the middle of halftime, think again. And again.