Royalties breakthrough: RIAA and media agree on streaming rates

By Scott M. Fulton, III | Published September 23, 2008, 5:08 PM

While legislation before Congress languishes in the midst of two wars and now a severe financial crisis, the major parties in the online music royalties debate have actually come to an agreement on compromise rates.

In a surprise announcement that could actually signal the beginning of the end of the long-running streaming media royalties debacle, representatives of the Recording Industry Association of America state they have reached an agreement with DiMA, the leading trade group representing digital media broadcasters. That agreement could cap the music royalties that streaming broadcasters pay to 10.5 percent of revenue.

BetaNews is seeking clarifications on the formula from the main parties involved. But here is one feature that the joint news from the RIAA, DiMA, and other parties appeared to make clear: Mechanical royalties -- what a streaming radio broadcaster like Pandora pays for distribution to songwriters, for the right to reproduce their work -- will be limited to 10.5% of revenue, for services that provide interaction or "limited download" capability (for instance, storing music in a cache to be listened to later, as opposed to downloading an MP3). It appears that formula includes revenue from both subscribers, if there is any, and advertising which accompanies the music online.

That amount will be reduced, the joint statement says, by the amount which each online broadcaster pays for performance royalties -- the amount which officially goes to artists. (In many cases, both allotments often end up going to the same copyright holders anyway, which are represented by the recording industry. Believe it or not, there's a third royalties tier that's apportioned specifically for copyright holders anyway.) While the matter of a fair performance royalty amount is still being debated in Congress, under this agreement, it would not be in anyone's best interests to set that rate at higher than 10.5% of net revenue. (Even the proper formula for determining "net revenue" is being debated in Congress.)

Here's where things could get tricky: According to today's joint statement, "Outside the scope of the draft regulations, the parties confirmed that non-interactive, audio-only streaming services do not require reproduction or distribution licenses from copyright owners."

Strange as this may seem, most streaming radio services over the Internet fall into that category -- for instance, Shoutcast. You can tune into a Shoutcast stream without using the Web; for Pandora, by comparison, there's a little bit of interaction involved. That could mean Shoutcast's mechanical royalties tier is reduced to zero, on the theory that an Internet-based radio player such as Winamp is more like a traditional AM/FM radio than it is a CD reproduction system.

But if Shoutcast's royalties formula starts at zero, then how can its fee be reduced by performance royalties? That 10.5% cap may be good news for Pandora because it sets a barrier for the other major tier; without such a barrier in place for non-interactive services, someone could concoct an argument saying Shoutcast's performance royalties fee should remain high. BetaNews has contacted the major parties involved, though since this news is so fresh, we expect clarification to come perhaps tomorrow.

Also according to today's statement, the playing of 30-second or shorter promotional music clips within ads, or in promoting music online for purchase (which Amazon and BN.com currently do), will not incur a mechanical royalty fee "in the interest of encouraging paid uses of musical compositions." This news comes just one day after the US' three top performance rights organizations, led by ASCAP, called for the imposition of new performance royalties for sound clips -- a move that met a swift, negative response from DiMA yesterday.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Any take on what's the impact on smaller independent stations such as SOMAFM?

Score: 0

|

"You can tune into a Shoutcast stream without using the Web; for Pandora, by comparison, there's a little bit of interaction involved. That could mean Shoutcast's mechanical royalties tier is reduced to zero, on the theory that an Internet-based radio player such as Winamp is more like a traditional AM/FM radio than it is a CD reproduction system."

If this comes to be true then AOL should cut streaming of Shoutcast from Winamp and just let it be streamable through online radio players like Nexus Radio. People may be upset, but oh well they'll get over it.

Score: 0

|

As if this actually matters...... The RIAA is really no different than the DEA and its so-called war on drugs. They are actually getting nowhere in the long run and have to make it look like they're doing something.

Like the DEA going after pot smokers while the real criminals get away.

Score: 0

|

So what's wrong with smoking weed??

Score: 0

|

"So what's wrong with smoking weed??"

Are you serious? I don't know one person over the age of 25 who smokes dope that isn't a complete s***less layabout loser who is only interested in making just enough money until thier next paycheck arrives and does just enough at thier job to not get fired.

Self loathers trying to escape from reality by getting stoned ...... wonderful.

Score: 0

|

Couldn't have said it better. Although some of them also escape reality by leaving stupid pro-drug comments on forums. Kind of a vicious cycle, really. Oh, and I really do hope that streaming radio is saved once and for all.

Score: 0

|

Pass over the bottle, Holly...

Score: 0

|

Uh, actually, it's only the types you described
who are careless enough to let you learn about
what they are or are not doing.

Score: 0

|

That's the people who smoke weed that make it obvious.

Not all of them are like this. In fact, most aren't.

What exactly is wrong with making enough money until your next paycheck? (not the latter part of this quote, which I also strongly dislike)

Do I have to make s*** loads of money all the time? Is it mandatory in your strange world?

Score: 0

|

Ironic that a person using the moniker "Hollywood" would be arguing against pot smoking. Hysterical.

Score: 0

|

After telling US to mind its own business, Kroes slaps caps on Rambus royalties

The holder of many patents worldwide pertaining to DDR memory offered to reduce its royalty stake in that technology, and today the EU said yes.

Why Apple succeeds, and always will

The company consistently plays by different rules, literally like David did in his battle against Goliath.

EC's Kroes to US senators: Mind your own business on Oracle + Sun

UPDATED The EU's antitrust chief told the United States Senate Tuesday that any merger that takes place in the world is more her affair than theirs.

Betanews Podcast: Rupert Murdoch and the buying stuff online problem

We'll have a more difficult time paying for online news if the underlying protocol for online payment has a big gaping hole in it.

In a peace offering to newspapers, Google offers a new news format

It's probably not a solution to the woes of major news publishers, but Living Stories may gather a few of those publishers together in search of one.

Google Maps doesn't prevent car accidents, only search accidents

This week, Google updated Maps for Android 3.3.1, adding topography, nearby points of interest, and error reporting.

DOJ: Microsoft interop docs are now 'substantially complete'

A major milestone in the US Government's oversight of Microsoft is passed, as the Justice Dept. is now saying the company's protocol documents make sense.

The $1 DVD rental debate: LA group says Redbox will lose movie makers $1B

A report from the Los Angeles Economic Development Corporation says cheap Redbox DVD rentals could seriously damage the movie business.

First impressions of Droid: Easy, breezy, friendly, if a little fat

Though it's not quite as well-polished as Apple's iPhone OS, the version of Android that Motorola's Droid phone sports is still a breeze to use.

Windows fix for TLS security bug still forthcoming, won't be Tuesday

Anyone looking for a fix for last month's discovery of a potentially serious security hole in TLS and SSL may have to wait until everyone is ready to act together.

Not the first, not the last, technology predictions for 2010

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: The real truth is probably that what went around in 2009, will come around to haunt us next year.