Senate votes to consider FISA bill with telco immunity

By Scott M. Fulton, III | Published December 17, 2007, 3:25 PM

A procedural hurdle that would have stopped debate on a controversial amendment to the FISA law failed in the US Senate early this afternoon.

By a vote of 76-10, the US Senate has voted to consider an amendment to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that contains a controversial provision granting telecommunications companies immunity from federal prosecution for having cooperated with the government in surveillance operations.

The procedural vote means that the provision, not only supported but mandated by President Bush as a requirement before it's signed into law, will be debated on the Senate floor. Amendments will likely be offered to the bill that strike the provision, including one from presidential candidate Sen. Chris Dodd (D - Conn.) and Sen. Russ Feingold (D - Wisc.).

And even if those amendments fail, the Senate version of the bill will have to be reconciled with a House version which omits immunity for telcos.

In a statement this afternoon, Sen. Feingold took his own party's leadership to task, condemning Majority Leader Harry Reid (D - Nev.) for having chosen the Intelligence Committee's version of the FISA legislation over the Judiciary Committee's version, backed by Sen. Patrick Leahy (D - Vt.), a staunch opponent of telco immunity.

"By choosing the Intelligence Committee bill over the Judiciary product," Feingold wrote this morning just prior to the noon vote on Capitol Hill, "Senator Reid has made things much tougher for those of us who think the courts -- not Congress -- should decide whether the companies deserve immunity. He's also made it an uphill struggle of those of us who want more court oversight of the broad new surveillance powers included in the bill."

For his own part, Sen. Leahy issued his own laments.

"This Administration violated FISA by conducting warrantless surveillance for more than five years," Leahy wrote this morning. "They got caught, and if they hadn't, they would probably still be doing it. When the public found out about the President's illegal surveillance of Americans, the Administration and the telephone companies were sued by citizens who believe their privacy and their rights were violated. Now the Administration is trying to get this Congress to terminate those lawsuits in order to insulate itself from accountability. We should not allow this to happen."

Sen. Reid's office has yet to issue a statement on the matter at mid-afternoon Monday, nor has the office of Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D - W.V.), who leads the Intelligence Committee that supports the immunity provision.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Being the President of the United States is like being God. You're not only immune from any prosecution or wrong doing, no matter what you do, you also have the power to forcefully cleanse others you dragged into the mud along with yourself. Gotta love it. They can debate this bill all they want, it will never pass unless the provisions of granting immunity are left intact. Bush already said he will vito any version without it. He has to. The telcos did his dirty work and he owes them for it.

Score: 0

|

Thats not true .!

Score: 0

|

I've heard that presidents are actually pretty powerless on paper.
Maybe the events in today's outer republic (USA/The World) is a reflection of our inner republic (our inner selves[apathy, doubt, fear, escape, etc.])

Score: 0

|

I say, let's give each other space to breath and live our lives.

Houston Police Chief Wants Surveillance Cameras In Private Homes
http://www.infowars.com/...wants_cams_in_homes.htm

FBI records audio from cell phone when it is turned off
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jb6UCKTXL9Y

Freedom road brother! There is no rest. Freedom is just the nature of our being. There is no end I say ;)

Score: 0

|

first link broken... if memory serves me right: was that to film caregivers & babysitters?

Score: 0

|

Thanks for the reply. Here's the fixed link.

Houston Police Chief Wants Surveillance Cameras In Private Homes
http://www.prisonplanet..../160206privatehomes.htm

I recall the babysitters one but this video focuses on all cell phones.

Score: 0

|

EC's Kroes to US senators: Mind your own business on Oracle + Sun

If the AP is accurate, the EU's antitrust chief just told the United States Senate that any merger that takes place in the world is more her affair than theirs.

What does AT&T's 'Mark the Spot' app say about service quality?

That's a question for Betanews readers to answer in comments to this post.

Windows fix for TLS security bug still forthcoming, won't be Tuesday

Anyone looking for a fix for last month's discovery of a potentially serious security hole in TLS and SSL may have to wait until everyone is ready to act together.

Google rolls out real-time search, Near Me Now, extended personalization

Over time, searches from PCs and mobile phones will grow even "more personalized." But what about user privacy and search results that give you "the truth"?

Betanews Podcast: Rupert Murdoch and the buying stuff online problem

We'll have a more difficult time paying for online news if the underlying protocol for online payment has a big gaping hole in it.

Not the first, not the last, technology predictions for 2010

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: The real truth is probably that what went around in 2009, will come around to haunt us next year.

Google Goggles: Hands on with the Shazam of the Real World

Google today unveiled Goggles, its visual search lab for Android devices that identifies objects by sight.

Microsoft: Windows 7 Family Pack wasn't 'pulled,' it just sold out

If you hurry, you may still be able to find the last Family Pack upgrade editions hanging around retail store shelves, but probably not so much online.

Clever iPhone game returns after being bumped over a name dispute

The game's simple concept and multitude of platforms and puzzles manage to pull off a retro, 8-bit style that's reminiscent of an old Atari game given a modern makeover.

Intel's marriage of CPU and GPU not ready for prime time

Although there will be an Intel component this month that can compute and plot in parallel, Betanews was told today, it won't be based on Project "Larrabee."

An alternative to Research in Motion's enterprise e-mail? There's an app for that

Good Technology today released an iPhone app compatible with its enterprise e-mail solution.