Sun Countersues Azul Systems

By Ed Oswald | Published May 4, 2006, 11:30 AM

Sun shot back at Azul Systems Wednesday, filing a countersuit against the hardware maker in U.S. District Court in San Jose, Calif. In the suit, the computer maker alleged that Azul infringed on six patents and violated trade secrets.

Azul filed for declaratory relief in mid-March, crying foul over what it called "exorbitant" fees and royalties, as well as Sun demanding part ownership in the company. The company alleged that Sun was threatening Azul with legal action for non-compliance.

Sun claims that Azul developed its products on technologies other than its own. "By hiring away key former Sun employees, Azul improperly accessed Sun's technology and plans, which enabled Azul to accelerate introduction of its products to market," the filing reads.

In a statement sent to BetaNews, Azul's lawyer Bob Haslam said Sun's actions were not surprising. He said the company had attempted to negotiate with Sun, however its "belligerent requests" had got the two sides nowhere. He also noted that Sun's original list of allegations was much longer than the suit filed in court Wednesday.

"This leads us to believe that we were right in seeking declaratory relief and we are confident we will prevail," he said. "This suit is not about Azul technology; this suit is about Sun and its predatory attempt to thwart Azul's innovative solution from penetrating the market."

The two companies have close ties. Azul's president and CEO Stephen DeWitt founded Cobalt Networks, which Sun acquired in 2000. Azul's chief marketing officer is Shahin Khan, who formerly was an executive with Sun. The two sides also offer competing applications that act as a central repository to run Java applications.

Sun accuses DeWitt and Khan of using their knowledge of Sun to hire away key employees, who are allegedly working on the identical technology at Azul.

View comments by with a score of at least

Breakthrough: AMD and Intel settle antitrust dispute, reach new cross-license agreement

The world's largest outstanding intellectual property dispute has come to a dramatic and unexpected close this morning.

HP to acquire 3Com for $2.7 B in cash, focus on China

A long and uncertain comeback trail comes to an end for the one-time network equipment giant.

Universities reject Kindle DX as a textbook replacement

Two universities running Kindle DX pilot programs have rejected the device.

Snow Leopard and Windows 7 still can't crack the netbook problem

Apple has killed Atom support in OS X 10.6.2 and Windows 7 Starter Edition is stripped of "basic" functionality.

Microsoft damage control after marketer claims Win7 inspired by Mac

Have you ever said anything you wish you could take back? Ever? No? Not even once? Well then, you won't sympathize with a mid-level Microsoft manager today.

Facebook for iPhone developer goes from Apple supporter to 'I quit!' in 3 months

Fed up with Apple's App Store policies, the developer of Facebook for iPhone has bailed on the iPhone.

Bing vs. Google rematch on video search

After Microsoft folds some old MSN Video features back into Bing, do they add to the search engine's functionality or take away?

Bing gets geekier with new Wolfram Alpha integration

Microsoft's Bing is now teamed up with Wolfram Alpha for computational search results.

New EU telecoms framework mandates user consent before getting cookies

Do you want a cookie? No. Do you want a cookie? No. Do you want a cookie? No. Do you want...Are you annoyed yet? That's a preview of 2011.

The Samsung Intrepid: A nice phone, if you can accept Windows Mobile

Samsung appears to have built solid enough hardware, but it's the software that seems uncomfortable and unintuitive.

A real beta process at work: Mozilla fires up Firefox 3.6 Beta 2

In the clearest sign yet that public input really does help the development process, a flurry of bug detections provoked Mozilla to release Beta 2 of the next Firefox.