Testimony ends on Day 3 of the Jammie Thomas-RIAA trial

By Angela Gunn | Published June 18, 2009, 8:53 AM

A rogue member of the gallery got cussed out for illicit gadget use, Jammie Thomas-Rasset hit her personal wall, and the jury pondered whether 'tis better to rip than to download as testimony in the RIAA trial of a Minnesota woman concluded on Wednesday.

Jammie Thomas-Rasset was calm and collected on Tuesday. On Wednesday she hit the wall, tearfully recounting the havoc the RIAA has wrought on her life since tapping her originally for a $5,000 payout. (Most citizens contacted with that offer-one-can't-refuse have chosen not to refuse it; Ms. Thomas-Rasset did refuse, and here we are.) She accused Dr. Doug Jacobson, the computer expert who testified Tuesday, of lying (though the jury was instructed to disregard those remarks). She said, again, that she didn't download the music and didn't know who might have, but was steadfast in refusing to pin blame on anyone in particular -- especially her kids.

Blogging for Recording Industry vs. the People, Marc Bourgeois noticed some RIAA moves that might not play well with the parents on the jury. In particular, the plaintiffs' attorney kept at Ms. Thomas-Rasset about alleged inconsistencies in what she'd said about her kids' computer use which was directly supervised (she first said), but not with her watching at every single minute (as she said later). It's hard to image how a single parent with four kids could gaze unwaveringly upon one kid on the computer; the RIAA seemed to find her later qualification inconsistent, but it's quite possible the jury will sympathize.

What about the trip to Best Buy? That was the kids; her oldest son got annoyed when a game wouldn't work and bashed the machine. And the subpoena? She did get a FedEx envelope from the cable company, but she assumed it was the usual terms-and-policies stuff and tossed it without opening. [Do many people just toss FedExes like that? -- AG] And all that music? Some of it was stuff she liked, she said, but many of those artists were platinum; other stuff, the death metal especially, was more to her ex's taste and nothing she'd play.

Ben Sheffner, still doing meticulous blogging work at Copyright and Campaigns, noted that at last Ms. Thomas-Rasset "told a story" -- that is, she explained how the heck she got the dates wrong, what she thinks might have happened, and even what that venerable "tereastarr" username was about. (Those were baby names she liked in case she ever had a daughter. Teenage girls do that sort of thing.) He wasn't sure that the ambiguity of her last pieces of testimony worked -- I didn't do it, but maybe my ex or the kids did, but I don't know, and I've been protecting them from these record company people, and -- but it fits in well with the defense argument that even if someone downloaded these tracks, there's no way of knowing who.

And then there was that rogue gadgethound. According to Twitter user @semiaccurate, also attending the trial faithfully this week, "P.S. jerk lawyer in the gallery caught with Blackberry, Judge Davis not amused, reads him the riot act before giving it back."

Closing argument are slated for today; each side will speak, but rebuttals are not scheduled to occur. The last iteration of Capitol v. Thomas was decided in a matter of hours, so a decision could come as early as today.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

With my ISP I can recognize the bill, but
everything else looks the same and is usually
a plea for me to sign up with them--I usually
toss the stuff unopened.
Now, if they sent me something by Fed Ex
(like they did for the modem when I signed up),
that I'd /Notice/.

Score: 0

|

"She said, again, that she didn't download the music and didn't know who might have, but was steadfast in refusing to pin blame on anyone in particular -- especially her kids."

She stated multiple times that if it was *anyone* in the house, it was either her son, or her Ex. She provided several explanations as to why it might have been her Ex. She may have stopped short of accusing him directly, but I wouldn't say she went out of her way *not* to....

"Do many people just toss FedExes like that? "

It's the bugblatter beat of traal syndrome. If they don't see the subpoena, it can't see them. :p

"and even what that venerable "tereastarr" username was about. (Those were baby names she liked in case she ever had a daughter. Teenage girls do that sort of thing.)"

Some people just shouldn't have kids... Terrea Starr Thompson? Really? The kid would've never made it past elementary.

As for it being blamed on the kids...Stupid move. Last I checked, parents were responsible for the actions of their kids..especially in circumstances where law is involved, though RIAA might have to take it to criminal court to run that route.

Paul, I agree 100%. A box of rocks could outwit this chick.

Score: -1

|

Is this woman blindingly stupid, or is it just me?

Score: 0

|

About as blind as a shined deer LOL.

Score: 0

|

In a somewhat similar case, any verdict yet on the case against RealNetworks? I've been waiting to see the outcome of that case as well as this case.

Score: 0

|

Latest Firefox 3.6 beta fixes 133 bugs, promises faster page load times

A once-sluggish beta testing process has kicked into overdrive, with astonishing success at finding serious bugs. Will Mozilla be able to fix all the others in time?

Apple invokes DMCA, claims Psystar is 'trafficking in circumvention devices'

In trying to close the book on possibly the last attempt at a Mac clone, Apple cites from its own landmark case...but may actually be misinterpreting it.

The fallacy of Facebook privacy

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: If an insurance company learns something interesting about its client through the Internet, is that snooping?

Microsoft 'worked with Apple' for Silverlight on iPhone, says Goldfarb

By not making such a big deal out of trying to stream video to the iPhone, Microsoft got a big deal out of it, revealed the Silverlight product manager.

Confirmed: Office 2010 to ship in June

Two weeks after Microsoft had been expected to draw a clearer roadmap for its principal applications suite, it's finally ready to commit to the end of H1.

New EU antitrust commissioner will oversee Microsoft, Oracle+Sun, Intel issues

As one of Europe's most prominent politicians shifts positions in January, her replacement remains a question mark over technology's biggest issues.

Without its own 'iTablet' yet, is Apple missing the boat?

Steve Jobs is on record as dissing "single-purpose" devices like e-readers. But given their recent popularity, was that a mistake?

Not-so-mobile battery life: Time to force the issue

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: If power efficiency is important when you buy a car or even a motorcycle, why shouldn't it matter for a smartphone?

Clicker.com cuts through the Web video chaos

In a world where homemade video and Hollywood movies travel the same pipeline, it's good to have a real search engine to cut through the clutter.

Microsoft's Ray Ozzie: 'Nobody's going to be 100% open'

The mobile apps ecosystems of the world may converge over time, led by apps being ported over across platforms, according to the Chief Software Architect.

A case study in improving software: What Office 2010 can learn from Notion 3

A music composition product gambles with a complete overhaul, in an effort to make headway against two well-known competitors in a tough market.