Virtual worlds firm files IP suit on Christmas Eve

By Angela Gunn | Published December 29, 2008, 7:00 PM

Worlds.com, which launched its first 3D avatar environment back in the mid-90s, has retained an intellectual property law firm and has filed patent infringement suits. Its first, against game developer NCsoft, was filed on Christmas Eve.

The company claims that NCsoft -- the publisher of Lineage and City of Heroes -- is infringing on two patents. The latest of the two, "System and method for enabling users to interact in a virtual space" (US Patent 7,181,690), was filed in August 2000 and awarded in February 2007. It describes a method for displaying other avatars and non-avatar objects (e.g., background items) to multiple users.

The earlier patent, "Scalable virtual world chat client-server system" (US Patent 6,219,045), was filed in November 1996 and awarded in April 2001. It describes how such a virtual world environment can be made scalable.

In mid-December, Worlds.com retained the IP-law firm Werner David and, in announcing the choice, specifically mentioned the two patents as protected intellectual property. Werner David's especially well-known for their work on biotech patent cases, but tech folk may be amused to hear that the firm has sued IBM and won while representing Diebold (the parent company of the e-voting machine maker), in a suit regarding ATM machines.

To make the litigation decision, Worlds.com worked with General Patent Corporation, the oldest (est. 1987) of the intellectual property management or (alternately) patent enforcement firms. Such firms usually first attempt to negotiate with companies that might be infringing on a client's patent. If this situation proceeds as have similar situations in the past, Worlds.com is likely to be pursuing licensing arrangements with a number of companies, perhaps larger firms such as Linden Labs (home of Second Life) or Blizzard Entertainment (home of World of Warcraft), turning to litigation when talks fail.

Tracking the situation over at Virtual Worlds News, publisher Christopher Sherman agrees that Worlds.com probably didn't simply decide earlier in the month to ignite the lawyers. "I would imagine they've met with some resistance from some of the major companies and therefore have been planning a litigation strategy for some time. Just my hunch."

Word from the licensing firm wouldn't seem to contradict that assessment. "The Worlds patents represent exceptionally valuable intellectual property," said Alexander Poltorak, GPC's chairman and CEO, in a press statement when the Lerner David retainer was announced. "We welcome licensing inquiries from the online game industry."

Worlds.com representatives weren't available for comment by our deadline.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Nice to see these people are a buncha patent trolls.. I used their product years ago and it was just awful.. So they waited for someone to do it better to snap the lawyers out.. Really think its time for patent reform.. if you don't use it or even attempt to keep it current you lose it....I love how they just threw up a update to it recently to make it appear is if its a current IP theft.. Worlds is as bad as SCO in the patent-trolling wading pool.. Tend to agree with the others. I hope they get clobbered on Prior-Art

Score: 0

|

The latest of the two, "System and method for enabling users to interact in a virtual space" (US Patent 7,181,690), was filed in August 2000

Ultima Online was *released* in September of 1997.

EverQuest, I believe, was released in March of 1999.

Based on the information in the article (didn't follow the links to the actual patents), they have nothing.

Why can't we sue these idiots for wasting taxpayer money and the courts time?

Score: 0

|

Exactly. This is nuts the kinds of things people sue for anymore. I mean give me a break. So they think they thought up the concept of a virtual world? IDTS; That's been in Novels for ages. Long before some of those idiots were even born was that concept thought of.

Whats next a Chemical bonding company patenting air? Take a breath and you are in violation of copyright... That's how ridiculous this feels.

Score: 0

|

Hell, "The Lawnmower Man" came out in 1994....

These guys are really bad at fishing...

Score: 0

|

Even better, "Tron" - 1982.

Score: 0

|

Two words: prior art.
Examples: MUDs, Crossfire.

Regards,
Ruemere

Score: 0

|

Wow, I haven't heard ANY news about worlds since MediaOne was pimping them when they were still around. I checked it out and thought "hey, that's neat you can chat like in cybertown.com"

Then I checked it years later and saw they made no improvements to the system using the same now outdated graphics. If they actually do something rather than just sue others to generate revenue that would be cool.

Score: 0

|

Microsoft's Ray Ozzie: 'Nobody's going to be 100% open'

The mobile apps ecosystems of the world may converge over time, led by apps being ported over across platforms, according to the Chief Software Architect.

Will Firefox beat IE9 to Direct2D rendering?

Just days after Microsoft executives gave conference attendees a peek at a new rendering technology, a Mozilla contributor revealed he's working on the same thing.

Where there's smoke: Apple warranty stance raises troubling questions

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: Smoking can be dangerous not only for your lungs, it appears, but for your Apple hardware warranty.

The fallacy of Facebook privacy

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: If an insurance company learns something interesting about its client through the Internet, is that snooping?

Microsoft 'worked with Apple' for Silverlight on iPhone, says Goldfarb

By not making such a big deal out of trying to stream video to the iPhone, Microsoft got a big deal out of it, revealed the Silverlight product manager.

Clicker.com cuts through the Web video chaos

In a world where homemade video and Hollywood movies travel the same pipeline, it's good to have a real search engine to cut through the clutter.

A case study in improving software: What Office 2010 can learn from Notion 3

A music composition product gambles with a complete overhaul, in an effort to make headway against two well-known competitors in a tough market.

Kindle 2 update adds battery life, native PDF reader

Amazon has pushed out an update to the Kindle 2 e-reader that lengthens battery life and adds a native PDF viewer.

Safari on iPhone gets competition from a $1 browser app

Apple likes to say it gives iPhone users a full browsing experience, but a new competitor tries to incorporate more desktop browser features.

Action Replay maker sues Microsoft for Xbox 360 'predatory technological barriers'

Third-party video game accessory maker Datel has filed an antitrust lawsuit against Microsoft over the Xbox 360's recent Dashboard update.