Login:
Password:

A Look Inside Windows Live Search

By Scott M. Fulton, III, BetaNews

September 12, 2006, 1:35 PM

In the Internet search space, Google has set a clear precedent: When you create a service, first you go with what you've got. Then when the bugs seem to have died down, you drop the word "beta" and you call it a launch. Late yesterday, Microsoft dropped the "beta" from Windows Live Search, the culmination of its original Live.com project the company "launched" last November.

In many ways, it's not the same service. Live.com tried a number of various approaches to the basic theme of Internet search, including an AJAX-driven application with customizable content boxes, similar to what Excite.com tried years earlier.

But at least for Windows Live Search, Microsoft has settled on a trimmed down approach that, while cleaner, looks and feels much closer to Google. The "Personalize Page" feature remains present, with a demure little link in the upper right corner, but Live.com no longer barrages the user with an example of how personalization could look.

In previous months, it was personalization that had been touted by Microsoft developers as the feature that will cast Live Search in an entirely new category, separate from Google's homepage. Last June, developers at the company's TechEd 2006 conference in Boston demonstrated rapidly generated Web services, called mashups, which admins could conceivably assemble with minimum effort, based on information services published through an XML-based model developed by Microsoft.

But for right now, the personalization feature is a little quieter, and harder to find than in earlier betas. On the surface, it enables users to choose which of four sub-pages -- "Basics," "News," "Sports," or "Entertainment" -- to attach to her Live.com startup page. Once one of these sub-pages is created, its name appears in the tab bar, which re-emerges after having been wiped clean from the startup page's current incarnation.

By clicking on "New Page," the user creates a blank tab. From there, "Add Stuff" brings up a directory of RSS news feeds and Live.com-associated news services. Some of these items that qualify under the class of "stuff" are "gadgets," and it's here -- at long last -- where users may at some future date find the mashups which were once considered the thing that made Live.com "live."

As some might expect for a "1.0" release, the gallery of gadgets right now is rather sparse. On the other hand, Microsoft has had several months to encourage third-party developers to produce mashups and other gadgets for this particular space, though the results of that campaign don't appear to be reflected here.

We also noted in early tests of the final version of Live.com that, once you create a customized "gadget page," for lack of a better word, the startup page can become mysteriously stark and devoid of content. The search bar, for instance, travels to the very top of the page, presumably to make way for tabs full of gadgets and mashups. If you wait as long as a minute, those tabbed pages will eventually appear.

The final version of the Image Search feature maintains the more animated approach that you'll see not only with Microsoft online services, but also with Windows Vista. A search for images brings up a series of thumbnails, whose size can be changed dynamically using a slider along the upper bar - Google's equivalent is provided by a drop-down box that switches between "small," "medium," and "large" sizes.

When you pass over the Live.com-provided image with the mouse pointer, it zooms closer to you, toward the center, and then becomes framed in an information box which reveals its source, and a link to the page that contains it.

When you click on the link, the thumbnails shift position to a single column along the left side, while the page containing it shows up in a frame toward the right. While Google's functionality is similar, its page elements don't flow from place to place; and some might argue, Google's less animated controls are therefore less intuitive.

Microsoft is touting Live.com's capability to produce lists of "related people" when performing an image search for clearly identifiable names - for example, a search for "Tom Cruise" may be irrevocably linked to "Matt Lauer." While I expected this feature to be limited to the obvious celebrities, I found it surprisingly useful with tests for more difficult-to-place names like "Richard Armitage," which Live.com accurately related to "Colin Powell" and "Valerie Plame."

Image search also features what Microsoft calls a "scratchpad." "Since we know most people searching on images want access to multiple images," Windows Live Search General Manager Ken Moss described on the company's blog on Monday, "this is a quick and easy way to save your results to access them later."

Stay in touch with BetaNews for more about how Microsoft intends to take Windows Live Search further into competition with Google, especially when it comes to such important matters as advertising revenue.

Add a Comment (9 Comments)

BetaNews reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic. Foul language and personal attacks will not be tolerated.

Name (required):

E-mail (required):

Enter Your Comment:

By bugmenot

posted Oct 19, 2006 - 12:46 AM

I tried MS Live, I think it's little better than Google. but the problem it doesn't work in FF search bar. How could it be fix?

Score: 0

By stuarti

posted Sep 14, 2006 - 9:27 PM

Very nice and much better than there previous MSN search, comes tops with me. Right time to change my preferred default search engine to LIVE :)

Score: 0

By gonealot

edited Sep 13, 2006 - 5:53 PM

Just tried MS's so called search. 3 searches, all correctly answered by Google and other search engines, were blown by Windows live search. My opinion, it don't do the job, It's just another Windows case of too little, too late.

Score: 0

By zridling

posted Sep 13, 2006 - 5:35 AM

Very nice!

Score: 0

By potheekaami

edited Sep 12, 2006 - 11:35 PM

I think Live.com, especially the image features. I think after a long long time good old Microsoft has really realeased something applaudable.

Let's see how it goes.

Score: 0

By Geminate

edited Sep 12, 2006 - 11:13 PM

Just click on 'Windows Live Search' words in the first paragraph or go to -http://www.live.com/

Score: 0

By kyleabaker

posted Sep 12, 2006 - 4:30 PM

the circle of dots was most definitly not orginal from firefox. it has been used for a very long time now by various programs. some flash files load with that icon. firefox didn't make it. infact, firefox was not original on much at all. i suppose they made tabbed browsing and ie7 is copying, lol, j/k. but i think the circle of dots is far older than firefox.

Score: 0

By samanathon

posted Sep 12, 2006 - 3:16 PM

Did anyone else notice that after you personalize your page and it's loading, it has the same rotating-dot-around-the-circle like Firefox does?

I'm not implying they tried to copy Firefox again, just thought it was noteworthy.

Score: 0

By ds0934

posted Sep 12, 2006 - 1:57 PM

"A look inside Windows Live Search"

Maybe it should read "A search of Windows Live Search"

Score: 0