Bezos says Kindle 1984 deletions were 'stupid', doesn't say how Amazon will solve illegal book problem

By Nate Mook | Published July 23, 2009, 7:15 PM

Nearly a week after it deleted illegal copies of George Orwell's 1984 and Animal Farm from customers' Kindles without warning, Amazon's CEO Jeff Bezos posted a personal apology to the Kindle user forums. Bezos called the company's handling of the decision "stupid," and said it would learn from the mistake. But he didn't say what would change, if anything.

This is an apology for the way we previously handled illegally sold copies of 1984 and other novels on Kindle. Our "solution" to the problem was stupid, thoughtless, and painfully out of line with our principles. It is wholly self-inflicted, and we deserve the criticism we've received. We will use the scar tissue from this painful mistake to help make better decisions going forward, ones that match our mission.

With deep apology to our customers,

Jeff Bezos Founder & CEO Amazon.com

As we reported last week, Amazon was able to remove the titles because the Kindle is configured to automatically sync up with the user's Bookshelf via the electronic book reader's WhisperNet wireless service. When the company removed the unauthorized books from customers' accounts, they also disappeared from the Kindle.

The media quickly jumped on the juicy and ironic news, often leaving out relevant information, such as the fact that the Orwell books were not authorized and were sold for only $1. It was also not the first time illegal books had been deleted from Kindles.

Amazon had already said in a press statement late last week that it would no longer delete copies of books sold to customers, even if they were found to be illegal. However, many people were still irked with the idea of Amazon having such control in the first place, as well as its poor communication about the situation, so a personal apology from Bezos should help smooth things over.

Customers quickly responded to the forum posting with positive comments. "I appreciate the admission; to be fair, I thought it was a matter of a lapse in judgment and counter to your company image. I'm happy with the resolution," wrote Geoffrey Snyder.

Many customers actually expressed no problems with how the situation was handled, but still appreciated the personal comment from Bezos. "If I unwittingly purchase an illegal copy of an ebook, I see no problem with Amazon deleting it from my Kindle as long as I get a straightforward explanation and an immediate refund. I have no desire to own stolen merchandise," wrote Peter Craine. "A lot of people seem to think an apology was necessary. I don't, but thanks anyway. Good for you."

"Your apology is deeply appreciated. However I take issue with your description of Amazon's actions as being "stupid, thoughtless, and painfully out of line with our principles. " I'm not sure that I would not have handled the situation any differently," wrote Ceres.

But missing from Bezos' apology (and Amazon's PR statement before it) is any information on how Amazon would avoid such problems in the future. Bezos acknowledged that Amazon had sold people "illegal" books that were published through the Kindle Store's self-serve system, yet didn't say this system would be changed.

One reason for this may be liability. If Amazon strictly moderates what content gets published, it could be held liable for copyrighted material being sold illicitly. For example, J.K. Rowling or Scholastic could theoretically sue Amazon for selling illegal copies of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Price last week; the e-book was pulled after about an hour. However, Amazon can currently claim that it doesn't decide what books get published, much like an ISP doesn't control what its users upload and download, which places the liability on the company submitting the material.

So will Amazon continue selling illegal books? It looks that way, at least for the time being. But Kindle customers can now rest easy knowing that they won't disappear mid-read.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Not enough done, we need cuts for this

Score: -2

|

PDC 2009: What have we learned this week?

There was the freebie that no one will forget, the heebie-jeebies courtesy of Scott Guthrie, and a teensy bit clearer picture of how this cloud thingie should work.

Live report: Will Google Chrome OS change Linux?

The mysteries of just what Chrome OS is, and how much of an operating system it truly is, may be resolved today.

PDC 2009: Microsoft cares about Web browser performance

The effort to give users of the world's dominant Web browser the impression of quality, is a personal one for the man who leads that battle.

Nokia re-affirms its commitment to Symbian, sort of

Maemo won't necessarily be replacing Symbian in the Nokia N-Series, but that's definitely a place where it will be found.

E-book readers will be in short supply this holiday season

E-readers are hot this year, and a lot of compelling new products have been released, but are there enough electrophoretic displays to go around?

Sony looks to finally open a single storefront for downloads

Sony has had many different download portals for movies, music, e-books, and games, and now it's looking to make a single shop for all of it.

Tuning out the tablet: Time to give the endless speculation a rest

Wide Angle Zoom: Wishing and hoping and thinking and praying....won't put an iTablet on the market.

Five improvements for IT managers in 2010

If businesses are to improve their efficiency for next year, they need to stop and reassess the basic tenets of their job.

AOL's spinoff from Time Warner to shed 2,500 jobs

As AOL moves toward become an independent company again, it will cut nearly a third of its workforce.

Gartner: SMS-based money transfer will be bigger than mobile browsing, search

Gartner issues its predictions for the 10 things our phones will be doing in 2012.

Don't forget to upgrade to Firefox 3.6 beta 3 today

Mozilla has released the latest beta its Firefox 3.6 browser software, just over one week after beta 2.