Microsoft, Mono developer form open source/commercial cooperative

By Scott M. Fulton, III | Published September 10, 2009, 6:53 PM

Perhaps Microsoft's most effective competitive effort to date against Linux has been its recent moves directly into the open source arena, fuzzifying the boundaries between open source and commercial software efforts and playing more like a participant than a conqueror. If it does anything at all, it makes efforts to continue characterizing Microsoft as an evildoer look like recent right-wing efforts to paint the Obama administration as the re-emergence of Joseph Stalin.

Those broad-brushstroke efforts will become even more difficult after today, now that the company has announced it has funded an independent organization -- an offshoot of its Codeplex counterpart to Linux' SourceForge -- to nurture and facilitate efforts for private software companies, including itself, to contribute intellectual property to open source development efforts.

"The Codeplex Foundation provides a framework to facilitate the participation of commercial software developers in open source projects, either through intellectual property contributions to the foundation or through time volunteered under the auspices of the foundation to enable development work on open source projects," reads the Codeplex Foundation's mission statement, published today. "The Codeplex Foundation also provides a channel of communication from the open source community back to Foundation partners and other commercial software companies, advancing the dialog between commercial software companies and open source communities."

The bylaws of the new foundation, published today, are essentially boilerplate legal documents enabling it to establish a board of directors and schedule meetings. But they paint a picture of a legitimate effort to bypass a future of IP litigation and legal disputes -- the likes of which have reduced companies such as SCO to almost powerless carcasses -- by making feasible real and substantive communication channels for developers who wish to build open source projects on the Windows platform, without fear of encroachment from commercial publishers' legal departments.

While the Codeplex Foundation's charter Advisory Board and Board of Directors are comprised mainly of prominent Microsoft employees, including .NET program manager Scott Hanselman, one of the first six directors is Miguel de Icaza, the popular and charismatic leader of the Mono project -- the .NET-compatible platform for Linux and Mac, funded by Novell with Microsoft's blessing. "This is another step in the right direction for Microsoft," de Icaza blogged today. "There are still many things that I would like to see Microsoft do, and many things that I believe Microsoft has to change to become a full member of the open source community, but it is encouraging to me to see Microsoft evolve. I hope that the CodePlex foundation will help us continue to build bridges between our communities."

For his part, Hanselman blogged today that he's had experience in the open source field, and knows first-hand what that community has to go through to make deals with commercial interests. "When I was working with Corillian/CheckFree, it was a challenge to get Open Source software used on big proprietary projects," he wrote. "There was fear and confusion at all levels. We eventually got it done, and there's open source software from then-Corillian running at large banks and small credit unions all over the world. In my opinion, if CodePlex.org succeeds, open source software will be used by more professional software developers."

Microsoft's move today comes just days after offering another huge olive branch to the open source community -- a move which, like most others, was greeted with immediate skepticism. The company sold a package of patents related to technology used in Linux, that Microsoft might otherwise have used in litigation against Linux developers and maybe even users, to a patent resale organization. That organization -- Allied Security Trust -- then immediately resold those patents to the Linux-friendly Open Invention Network, in a two-part transaction that all parties admit was planned this way. But that is not how some in the Linux community characterized the move. Yesterday, Linux Foundation Director Jim Zemlin praised OIN for, as he described it, saving the Linux-related patents from being absorbed by patent trolls -- which Zemlin contends must have been Microsoft's original motive.

"By selling patents that target Linux, Microsoft could help generate fear, uncertainty, and doubt about Linux, without needing to attack the Linux community directly in their own name," Zemlin wrote. "This deal shows the mechanisms the Linux industry has constructed to defend Linux are working, even though the outcome also shows Microsoft to continue to act antagonistically to its customers. We can be thankful that these patents didn't fall into the hands of a patent troll who has no customers and thus cares not about customer or public backlash."

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Today's Microsoft is not the one we had in the nineties. They thought first in the user's needs, and we all loved them.
Now they only mind their own business: complex solutions for simple problems.
Charity, but not towards their customers.
I don't imagine them providing any open source software, unless it means a path to big money.

Score: -1

|

You know, this makes me wonder if M$ becoming part of the Open Source Community is in it's best interest; Is it commercially viable? The patent sale does propose one way of making money: Auction off the intellectual property that could be used to hold others hostage. All they have to do is stay one step ahead technologically and the trick can be done again and again. Of course if this were the real world (not the Business world), and this were being done with WMD's nobody would stand for it. *sigh*

Score: -2

|

Seriously? M$? The company does more charity work then any other company and you complain they are making money? Its old and it makes you look like a tool...

Score: -1

|

BHO hasn't achieved Stalin status yet. He's trying though.

Score: -2

|

wrong, although SLP is Hitler

Score: -2

|

I would say that the codeplex foundation kinda sounds like it mimics the FSF, but given their hippy like nature, I can see why MS would want to not be associated with them. Freakin bunch of loonies they are

Score: -1

|

Indeed.....I appreciate what RMS has done in starting the FOSS movement........but the guy is a fruit cake.

Score: -1

|

Google Buzz: Another attempt to harness the content firehose

Similar to how Google successfully remolded RSS into a Google tool, the company now wants to remold Gmail into one big Google party

Success: Google's Nexus One shipping support line takes tech support questions

UPDATED Though the support line had been set up for shipping, it now appears Google personnel are happy to hear technical concerns.

Goodnight, moon: What I learned from a space shuttle

Carmi Levy | Wide Angle Zoom: Can the tech sector learn a few lessons from the space program? Certainly, if you believe in learning from someone else's mistakes.

Netflix to FCC: NBCU + Comcast could bypass net neutrality

Weaning itself from the post office as its main means of video transfer, Netflix would like someone to ensure the Internet remains just as unencumbered.

Rhapsody to become an independent company

RealNetworks and Viacom subsidiary MTV Networks have begun the process of spinning off music service Rhapsody into an independent company.

Nvidia debuts new dynamically-switched graphics card technology

Today, Nvidia announced that its Optimus technology for GPU switching will soon be available in a handful of Asus notebooks.

Google lowers 'unusually high' early termination fee on Nexus One

Google has lowered the Nexus One's early termination fees which were twice as high as the norm.

Netgear and Ericsson introduce a mobile broadband hotspot with a twist

It's a mobile broadband hotspot, but it's for use in the home.

Report: Streaming video drove 72% global increase in mobile data consumption

A new study says streaming video is "the single most influential factor driving the need for increased mobile network capacity."

Stymied by continuing Nexus One 3G issues, Google blames the environment

If you're still afflicted with the 3G flip-flop trouble, then you might consider moving. That appears to be the only suggestion Google can give for now.

Wolfram|Alpha makes a strong argument for virtual keyboards

"Answer engine" Wolfram|Alpha has updated its iPhone/iPod Touch app, harnessing the strength of the virtual keyboard.