Not exactly Bing 2.0: Latest 'Visual Search' feature fails to impress

By Scott M. Fulton, III | Published September 14, 2009, 4:32 PM

Last week, in what was probably an intentional promotional ploy, Microsoft showed off to some of its 40,000 employees and close colleagues, during an employee rally at Seattle's Safeco Field, some features of what it was touting as "Bing 2.0," with a warning that users everywhere could start to see these features go live as soon as today. While there is no official word of a "Bing 2.0" launch, one new feature has gone live today, and not quietly -- its curtain was officially raised during a ceremony at the TechCrunch50 conference in San Francisco today.

Visual Search is being described as a way to search for items by sight instead of by text. Shoppers will be able to locate digital cameras, for example, says Microsoft, by way of "an engaging visual experience without having to sort through page after page of links."

That's an accurate description, as Betanews discovered this afternoon. Digital Cameras -- one of several dozen visual categories compiled for Bing -- brings together 1,562 pictures of cameras, all on one page. Imagine a massive 3D Rolodex file of flappable images controlled using a single slider, all facilitated by Microsoft's Silverlight. By default, they're in alphabetical order by model name, so "Casio Exilim" appears under "E," not "C." Alternately, you can organize these photos by relative popularity among Bing users -- all 1,562 of them, ranked top to bottom. It's here where you learn that the Nikon D90 is ranked dead last in this category -- the same camera that scored 9.9 out of 10 on gdgt.com.

Do you see that digital camera you've had your heart set on, amid this page full of nearly 2,000 cameras on Bing?

If you've never been overwhelmed by a department store full of 50 or so digital cameras for you to choose from, all laid out as though you can tell the qualitative difference through osmosis, then you'll be equally unfazed by seeing 1,562 cameras presented on Bing's magical Silverlight escalator.

And when you get tired of shopping for cameras, you can change course and start shopping for politicians. Among Bing's new Visual Galleries unveiled today is a similarly rotating roster of the nation's federal office holders and chief executives, including from Congress, the gubernatorial ranks (though no lieutenant governors), along with the President, his cabinet, and the Vice President. Here you can make comparisons between which office holders smile with their mouths open versus closed, who stands or remains seated for their official portraits, and who likes to be seen in front of books. You do have criteria for narrowing the list by subcategories, such as by represented state, party, and gender.

It's either the stuff of parades or nightmares: American politicians pass by you on a treadmill, in Bing Visual Search.

Although one does feel a certain feeling of awe at seeing the nation's many elected officials parade their faces before you in waves upon waves, like Space Invaders, at some point you find yourself wondering just how long Microsoft expected this feeling to last. Despite competitor Google's tendency to give historic weight to every incremental change ("We increased the point size on our search box...Alert the media!"), its search enhancements typically appear to have been made in the interest of facilitating a type of search that everyday folks actually perform, as opposed to necessitating the installation or update of some plug-in.

With Visual Search for US Politicians, just exactly what kind of search did Microsoft expect users to really perform here? Let's see, I'm looking for some redhead guy I saw on the news, I think he's in Congress...nope, not him...not him...no...definitely no... In the real world, there may be a possibility that someone's looking for a fellow who looks like Sen. Robert Byrd (D. - W.V.). In which case, she's more likely to type "Robert Byrd" in the search box.

And even though the gallery's icon is a portrait of Pres. Obama, try to imagine, if you would, the circumstances an everyday user would be in where he would need to be able to pick the President of the United States out of a line-up of 607 prominent federal and state office holders. Mr. Obama may have one of the most recognized faces in all the world today; anyone who needs help picking him out of a line-up has been buried in a spider hole for way too long, and is beyond Bing's help.

Finally, Microsoft invites you to "look for that movie you wanted to see." This feature is demonstrated using a selection of movie posters for the Top 100 Films in History through the entire last century of filmmaking, as determined by the American Film Institute. A Clockwork Orange appears on this list, although Patton and Dr. Zhivago do not; Nashville and Bonnie and Clyde appear here, although Little Big Man doesn't; Unforgiven appears here, while A Fistful of Dollars doesn't. The movie I want to see at this point is called, "What Were They Smoking?"

The extent to which Microsoft didn't really think this gallery out is revealed by, ironically, the search box. Suppose you're looking for a movie whose poster you can't find (maybe because The African Queen is filed under "T" instead of "A"), or a politician whose coif you don't see here, or a camera whose shade of silver doesn't match any of those you see in the photos. If you type its name in the search box, the gallery won't tell you it's not there -- instead, Bing takes you to perhaps you should have been in the first place: the regular search area, where you'll find "page after page of links."

Bing's Visual Search is yet another feature in search of a context. Most new Google features are functions in search of the visual tools necessary to make them usable and adaptable; Visual Search appears to have been inspired by the need to make Silverlight do something in Bing other than grow links on trees. There's a good chance a few more people today will have installed Silverlight 3.0 for the first time, but they will end up not being any more impressed with Bing than they were before, and that could come back to haunt Microsoft.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

Me too love microsoft extemely well... But don't know which search engine will hang on in top..

http://www.i-netsolution.com

Score: -1

|

Bing is crap. I love Microsoft but I'll remain a Google Search and Gmail user for at least a few more years, it seems...

Score: 0

|

Yeah, but they've disabled tabbed browsing (or
not enabled it)--they don't get that I may see a fun
thing not related to my search that I'll want to play
with later.

Score: 1

|

Fails to impress? Just look at all of that eye candy! That was the entire purpose of this new Bing search and I'd say it exceeds all expectations. Bing 2.1 will probably be designed to be an easy to use search engine.

Score: -2

|

This is actually pretty freaking cool, and I've already found a few uses for this beyond the examples given.

Score: 1

|

It is amusing that the rest of the tech press is almost universally ranging from "impressed" to "like a lot" on this one.

Score: 0

|

it's not that bad at all!! bing has become my new default search engine a few weeks ago, and i'm happy with it

Score: 1

|

You're really one of the most boring freaks I've ever known. Jump off the baby's arm holding an Apple Mac.

Whoever came up with this idea; judge it with an open mind.
Keep in mind that there are a lot of mentally ill, hard of learning, and generally uneducated people who use the internet on a daily basis. I think visuals over text is a good way to go for this kind of market.
Google will always be fine for me, I think, but it's good to know that people are pushing the boundaries.

Score: 5

|

Guess fatty doesn't have enough grey stuff when he refers to MS as "king of super expensive proprietary software."

Well, last time I checked Apple is more expensive than Microsoft...including hardware...

take a walk Mactard...

Score: 3

|

I think that this is fantastic. Believe it or not, visual is a great move for Bing's search. Microsoft, great job.

Score: 0

|

"Alternately, you can organize these photos by relative popularity among Bing users -- all 1,562 of them, ranked top to bottom."

Where is your editor?!

Score: -3

|

It's become a fashion with bloggers to dismiss anything Microsoft. I bet this article would have read different if the same thing had been done by Google or Apple...

Example : the author derides the way the Cameras are shown...yes, it's too much at first, but if you hover over a camera, you get quick details of each camera...and you can always "Narrow your search" down to the right one you are searching...

There are millions of things people search for and almost anything can be put down to a category...and MS has started off in the right direction...good example : Periodic table...imagine a HS student...one can quickly organize them by atomic weight or when discovered...

Grow up and give credit where's due...

Score: 3

|

like i did, searched by MP ;) found a select bunch of nice cameras
and why would he think the Nikon would be the most popular camera? when its not even affordable lol
obviously thats where the Canon model came from
the visual search is nice needs lots of tweaking though

Score: 2

|

"If you hover over a camera..." For a moment, put yourself in the mind of a user searching for cameras. _Why would you do this?_ Why would you hover over a camera? Probably because you are perusing each one, individually, in a desperate search for information. Now, just as I would rather not be flipping through each digital camera in a _real_ card catalog, why should anyone have to do this in a _virtual_ one?

Or put another way: Why should it be a "feature" to "narrow your search" when the net should not have been cast that wide in the first place? If I want to search for "Olympia Snowe," I'll type "Olympia Snowe." I won't be looking through a treadmill of federal office holders looking for a lady with dark hair in a bun.

Rational people don't search this way -- at least not anymore, not since the invention of the search engine.

But what's more important here: Why aren't there any shades of grey anymore? It seems I can't praise anything Microsoft does (Media Center) without being accused of taking funds under the table, and I can't take Microsoft to task (Visual Search) without being accused of being some kind of...young...blogger person. I swear, if I were to have a psychological examination performed on a certain small segment of our readers, and the examiner were to start to give them a pattern to fill in, like "1, 3, 5, 7..." by the time he got to "1" they'd be shouting, "Fifty-eight thousand nine hundred seventeen!!!"

And I'm afraid I've done maybe too much of the growing up thing...if I do any more of that, let's just say I won't be around much.

Score: 1

|

its a beta... i'm sure later on you'll be able to refine your search if the feature sticks

Score: 2

|

don't more key words narrow down a search? well in this beta there are no narrowing key words, so why would you expect the net to not be wide at first? ... i wouldn't, i would however expect it in the future

Score: 1

|

Regarding the looking for a lady with a bun: I would love for Bing\Google to let me upload an image and tell me who the hell it is. Or ID an MP3 for me. Some things you just can't type. Luckily, there's Shazam for my G1.

Score: -1

|

PDC 2009: What have we learned this week?

There was the freebie that no one will forget, the heebie-jeebies courtesy of Scott Guthrie, and a teensy bit clearer picture of how this cloud thingie should work.

Live report: Will Google Chrome OS change Linux?

The mysteries of just what Chrome OS is, and how much of an operating system it truly is, may be resolved today.

PDC 2009: Microsoft cares about Web browser performance

The effort to give users of the world's dominant Web browser the impression of quality, is a personal one for the man who leads that battle.

Nokia re-affirms its commitment to Symbian, sort of

Maemo won't necessarily be replacing Symbian in the Nokia N-Series, but that's definitely a place where it will be found.

E-book readers will be in short supply this holiday season

E-readers are hot this year, and a lot of compelling new products have been released, but are there enough electrophoretic displays to go around?

Sony looks to finally open a single storefront for downloads

Sony has had many different download portals for movies, music, e-books, and games, and now it's looking to make a single shop for all of it.

Tuning out the tablet: Time to give the endless speculation a rest

Wide Angle Zoom: Wishing and hoping and thinking and praying....won't put an iTablet on the market.

Five improvements for IT managers in 2010

If businesses are to improve their efficiency for next year, they need to stop and reassess the basic tenets of their job.

AOL's spinoff from Time Warner to shed 2,500 jobs

As AOL moves toward become an independent company again, it will cut nearly a third of its workforce.

Gartner: SMS-based money transfer will be bigger than mobile browsing, search

Gartner issues its predictions for the 10 things our phones will be doing in 2012.

Don't forget to upgrade to Firefox 3.6 beta 3 today

Mozilla has released the latest beta its Firefox 3.6 browser software, just over one week after beta 2.