The age of egregious Auto-tuning: 1998-2009

By Tim Conneally | Published June 15, 2009, 4:53 PM

When Antares Audio Technologies founder Andy Hildebrand filed for the patent for his digital pitch correction technology more than ten years ago, I wonder if he ever thought that it would be such an inescapable and controversial part of modern music.

Up Tempo with Tim Conneally regular feature badgeAfter the pop-consuming world was exposed to producer Mark Taylor's use of the inhuman, disjointed vocal effect on Cher in her 1998 single Believe, Antares Auto-tune and its scions became a mandatory fixture in any modern studio. Soon, it catapulted to the position of best-selling audio plug-in of all time. This tool could turn weak tones into strong ones, add vibrato to held notes, and turn a mediocre (or even terrible) singer into a good one, provided a certain willingness to overlook the cyborg-sounding artifacts.

Recording magazine called it the "holy grail of recording," and the technology has reached critical mass in the pop charts, with new songs every day blatantly using it. Kanye West relied almost totally on the plug-in to create his 2008 album 808s and Heartbreak, and robotic auto-tuning has become a stylistic trademark of 8-time Grammy award nominated producer T-Pain. Even Bob Mould, the frontman of '80s punk legends Husker Du used the plug-in throughout his Body of Song solo album.

Why even your humble correspondent was auto-tuned once. At the behest of my bandmates for a single we recorded in 1999, my vocals were digitally corrected. At first it sounded neat, but I then became acutely aware of the auto-tune squawk and could pick it up in everything, even in its subtle uses where a decent singer used it to make his vocals perfect. I used to look at it as artifice because I frequently meet people who couldn't identify an auto-tuned singer if she was glitching her way through an a capella rendition of "Happy Birthday."

This could be because of the even more obvious vocal trickery that has existed since the Second World War with techniques such as Sonovox or Talkboxing, which involves using the human mouth to shape amplified instrument sounds (like Peter Frampton's guitar in Do you Feel Like we do in 1973); and later Musical Vocoding, which uses the signal from a microphone to modulate synthesizer sounds (such as those heard in Electric Light Orchestra's Mr. Blue Sky.) Hildebrand's invention differs in that it is based on capturing loops and re-sampling them at a different pitch.

According to the Auto-Tune patent, "The period of the waveform is then compared to a desired period or periods (such as found in a scale). The ratio of the waveform period and the desired period is computed to re-sample the waveform. This ratio is smoothed over time to remove instantaneous output pitch changes. The ratio is used to resample the input waveform. The resulting output waveform is processed through a digital-to-analog converter and output through audio interfaces."

Apparently, waves of professional musicians have heard just about enough of the technology, and have begun to take a stand against the overuse of Antares' famous plug-in. The band Death Cab for Cutie showed up to the Grammy Awards last February wearing blue awareness ribbons which represented auto-tune abuse. Death Cab's lead singer Ben Gibbard, who endorses Real's Rhapsody service, said, "Auto-tuning is...affecting literally thousands of singers today and thousands of records that are coming out. We just want to raise awareness while we're here and try to bring back the blue note... The note that's not so perfectly in pitch and just gives the recording some soul and some kind of real character. It's how people really sing."

Last week, Jay-Z took a big swipe at the rap community's overuse of the technology by releasing a song entitled "D.O.A." or "Death of Auto-Tune."

Within the song, Jay-Z declares, "This is Anti-Autotune, death of the ringtone, this ain't for iTunes, this ain't for sing-alongs..." Later, he goes on to call for a moment of silence for Auto-tune and breaks into an extremely off-key rendition of Steam's "Na Na Hey Hey Kiss Him Goodbye."

As foul as Jay-Z's singing is in that section, it is at least genuine, and in a genre of music where catchiness and credibility are always at odds with one another, he is taking a definite stand. Pop music, on the other hand, is a big copycat game. One person will strike out in a new direction, and if it is successful, a hundred imitators will pop up doing the same thing. So if enough stars speak out against auto-tuning, such as Gibbard and Death Cab for Cutie, maybe the bar will be raised again for vocalists and Auto-tune will be used simply as a corrective tool, not the brush with which entire murals are painted.

Comments

View comments by with a score of at least

The problem is that as long as the music business looks for pretty faces with hot bodies who can -in certain cases- dance their butt off instead of searching for musical talent like in decades past (the early 80s being perhaps the last time we saw this), the auto-tune will not go out of style.

People like Billy Joel, Pixies, The Clash, etc. would've had a hard time making it in the current market since they lacked the "look and style" that could be marketable.

Score: 0

|

I like this effect, it's here to stay by the way.

My favorite use so far - Jaded Love by Trona

Score: 0

|

Sadly, it's usually the record label that demands certain measures be taken with the recorded work during post-production before it reaches the masses. Artists rarely have much say in the matter these days... unless they've been around for decades / own their own label.

Same goes for the "louder is better" trend over the past decade. It's ruining the music. Dynamics are practically non-existent... like a giant wall of white noise that gets tiring to the ears after a short while (Rush - Vapor Trails comes to mind). It's essentially the same as trying to read something printed in all-CAPS. The human brain gets tired of trying to process it after a while, and needs those subtle cues here and there. It needs a break!

No mastering engineer would intentionally do something like that to a recording on his / her own. They have pressure from label execs to not put out the quietest album in someone's playlist... sound quality be damned. To avoid being blackballed, they comply... and we're soon privileged to own an album marred with no dynamics, a lifeless soundstage, and digital clipping galore. Whoopie...

Score: 0

|

Wait a second...

are, .. .. .. are you saying that Cher can't sing?

Score: 0

|

Get rid of overdubs, get rid of separate takes, get rid of orchestras backing up rock bands (if they aren't in your lineup they don't belong on the record), there are so many production tricks that make music sound artificial, auto-tune is just one of them.

Score: 1

|

Yes I know what you're saying, but overdubs, separate takes and orchestras still are the actual performance of a musician. Reverb, compression and other effects don't fundamentally improve the performance of a singer. Intonation has always been part of the skill of a good singer, but with autotune and vocoders you can be a half step away from the right note and have it 'fixed' by a computer. I also don't like time-aligning or quantized drum parts (which are in nearly every recording by a major label now), but that's a discussion for another day. Call me old-fashioned, but I'm positive if people knew what is fixed in the studio they would lose a ton of respect for a lot of the music they listen to.

Score: 0

|

I really hope the end of Auto-Tune is near, but like you said, not enough people know they're hearing it. They just think that Rascal Flatts is that good of a singer. I experienced the same thing you did in the studio with a band. Once I heard my voice with and without Auto-Tune I can hear it a mile away, even if subtly used. I want human flaws back in music. It sounds more rich. Otherwise, I want a sticker on every AT'd record stating "actual vocals may vary".

Score: 0

|

Google Chrome 4: Yes, it's fast, but is it usable?

As Betanews readers have responded to our stories about Chrome's JavaScript superiority...Does that mean we'd actually use this browser? Well...

Video: Netflix on PlayStation 3

Netflix has come to the PlayStation 3 via Blu-ray and BD-Live.

Verizon Wireless launches new Android, Chocolate, and ruggedized phones

The lower-priced Eris joins the Droid, while the Chocolate gets a touchscreen and more music playback.

Early sales figures for Windows 7 nicely high, but do we know why?

Fans of triple-digit surges in figures quoted by Betanews will love this one, as it appears Microsoft rediscovered how to pull off a software launch.

Myka announces its latest Linux-based 'net top box'

Myka's ION brings Boxee, XMBC, and much more to HDTVs.

What hath Mac wrought? A remembrance after a quarter-century

The reason there's a Macintosh today is not because of some brilliant flash of engineering genius, but because Apple had the audacity to learn from its mistakes.

Early build of Moblin 2.1 improves connectivity, but not device support

The Linux Foundation's Atom-centric OS yesterday received a major overhaul with the project release of Moblin 2.1 for netbooks and nettops.

The iPhone's China syndrome: Sales of 5,000 and climbing

There's actually a country where Apple's device is not a godsend, where sales can be measured in the dozens.

New European counterpart to FCC will ensure 'a more neutral net'

Late Thursday night, the ruling telecom administrators of the EU's member nations signed away their final authority to a new entity overseen by the EC.

Sophos study suggests Windows 7 UAC's default setting is self-defeating

Without any anti-virus installed, a Sophos test showed, User Account Control was only capable of thwarting just one malware package out of ten samples chosen.

Indiscreet tweet trips awareness of Web SSL vulnerability

A group of high-level security engineers had been making progress on thwarting a low-level threat to the Web, until somebody blurted it all out on Twitter.