Final Cut Pro X is Mac App Store's top seller, but buyer reviews are scathing

Final Cut Pro X

Apple only released the software today, but Final Cut Pro X already is a hit. Perhaps that big price reduction -- to $299.99 -- has something to do with buyers' enthusiasm. Motion 5 and Compressor 4, which also released today for $49.99 a piece, rank second and fourth, respectively. Too bad so many of buyers' give the software a 1-star rating.

But there's more, and it's a wonder anyone else other than Apple is profiting from Mac App Store. Today's introductions put Apple products as the top-7 paid apps. There's an eighth, with iPhoto as No. 9. T-boneapps.com's iSplash, which is on sale today for 80-percent off -- that's 99 cents -- is No. 8, while Angry Birds is tenth.

Apple products command 10 of the top-12 paid ones. Is Apple just a better developer, or is there something of a home field advantage at work?

Earlier today, I observed that people wanting Final Cut Pro X would need Mac OS X 10.6 Snow Leopard (or Lion when it comes out) to buy and to use the software. Mac App Store is add-on to the one product and built-in to the other. The video-production software is available "exclusively from the Mac App Store", according to Apple -- direct digital download. I contended the distribution method will compel many people wanting Final Cut Pro X but using older OS X version to upgrade.

"It couldn't possibly be that they lowered the price to help drive sales realizing that they would appeal to a much larger audience at $300 vs $1000?" Betanews reader Matt Shulman asks in comments. "Sell 4 copies at $300 vs 1 copy at $1,000 and you're making more money and potentially getting more customers hooked on it. At $1,000, many people wouldn't even bother using a trial version (if it's available) simply because they wouldn't consider spending that much. At $300 though, it's far more likely".

That's sound reasoning, and Final Cut Pro X's top-sales status proves the point.

Still, for a top seller, lots of people aren't loving it. As I write, the average review is 2.5 stars, with the majority of buyers -- 102 out of 220 ratings -- giving Final Cut Pro X one star. Yikes!

Final Cut Pro X buyer Rjjfam shares his experience on the product page in the Mac App Store:

I'm working on a 8 core Mac Pro and have been working with FCP for almost a decade. I was working on a project and got the word that FCP X was available for download. I closed FCP 7 and purchased FCP X downloaded and installed it. The first thing I noticed was an icon to import IMovie Events. Are you serious?? iMovie -- the same program my aunt uses to edit videos of her weddings and kid birthday parties. I'm a professional, editing videos for broadcast television and have never used anything other than FCP!

So I go to open my project in FCP X and it won't open. It turns out that FCP X is not backwards compatible with any previous version of FCP. You can import iMovie Events but not FCP? WOW!!! So now I'm back to FCP 7 to finish up my projects and will revise this review if FCP X turns out to be what me and all of my fellow FCP users expected. But right now I will give it 1 star, because it should be told to perspective buyers that you cant use it with FCP 7 and older projects.

"What a joke! Don't waste your money!" gripes reviewer krnlb, who gives Final Cut Pro X just one star. "It is just iMovie on steroids." Cesar Peynetti: "Should be renamed iMovie Pro."

Kenneth Stillman, who is "incredibly disappointed", also gives the software a single star. He writes:

Forget that it's just confusing right out of the gate. Simple things like editing a multiclip are just a complete mystery to find. I can't figure out how to put in a slug, I need two seconds of black before the video starts. I do a lot of music video and I like to tap out the beat of the song. Forget in FCPX. It doesn't create audio markers in real time the way FCP 7 did. I just want to shoot myself because I wasted $300, and I somehow have to explain this to my wife.

There are supposedly 70 5-star reviews, but they were tough to find. Five-star rater Satyender Mahajan described Final Cut Pro X as an "excellent editor" that is "responsive" with an "elegantly-designed interface". Kell Gallaher calls the software "just awesome".

How about you? Did you buy Final Cut Pro X? How do you like it? Please answer in comments.

35 Responses to Final Cut Pro X is Mac App Store's top seller, but buyer reviews are scathing

© 1998-2024 BetaNews, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy - Cookie Policy.